Pietro's Italian Market — Attraction in Plumsted Township

I ordered from Pietro's Italian Market via DoorDash and had mixed feelings. First, $20 for a sandwich or salad is pretty steep, even with premium ingredients. There’s no way to tell portion sizes on DoorDash, so I expected a standard lunch-sized meal—but what I got was enormous. The sandwich was stacked inches thick with cold cuts, to the point where it was actually heavy. While impressive, it wasn’t quite what I was looking for—I just wanted a regular-sized sandwich, not something that felt like a meal for two. I couldn’t finish more than half and felt guilty wasting food and money.

The salad, which I ate the next day, was also massive and packed with toppings. Despite not eating it fresh, it was still enjoyable and just as filling as the sandwich had been. That said, I wasn’t a fan of how the romaine lettuce was shredded down to the core—there were too many hard, unappetizing pieces. Also, I love onions, and there just weren’t enough on the sandwich for my taste.

For the price, the portions are technically worth it, but I really wish they had smaller options—a half-sandwich or half-salad for a lower price, or even a lunch special for individual meals. If they offered those, I’d order from them regularly. That being said, the food quality shows they care about what they’re doing. If they add more portion options, I’d be happy to make this a go-to lunch spot.

Thank you—hope to see some changes on...

Many times in life one encounters many reasons to use F words...Well, the words for today were Fantastic Fresh Food, Fetching Feast for the eyes, Friendly Family oriented staff, Fits in well with our town. Went there today for the 1st time and I am amazed by how enticing everything displayed is. Being reactive to many foods I carefully picked from the buffet of delicacies behind the glass. The man serving me kept a smile on his face and held polite conversation with me as I chose small doses of things to try, the seafood salad and roasted broccoli. Upon splitting the food with my son, I realized 2 mistakes I made...1) Offering to share with him to begin with lol 2) getting only 2 small containers.Not even 3 hours later, we ended up calling in an order of fried calamari, picked up more seafood salad, and had to try the grilled chicken ...as well as picking up some amazing looking cookies from the table. I know Pietro's Italian Market will be getting more patronage from my family and I, the food and prices are very much worth it. If you get a chance to stop in, please do, and try as much of the food as possible, and smile to the staff, they are...

First time Coming here and ordered a California Cheese Steak. The worsed Sandwich ever who makes a Cheesesteak with the lettuce & the tomatoes on the bottom of the cheese steak with ketchup. I’ve never asked for ketchup for one & two never even added the oil & vinegar by the time I got home I had fried onions on top and lettuce & tomato on bottom. People if you’re going to hired a cook teach them how a Sandwich is Made this was the most Sloppiest & disgusting Sandwich ever. Never...