America’s Oldest Restaurant Is a 350-Year-Old Tavern Just 40 Minutes From NYC — Once Known As “America’s Spy Prison”

Step back in time without leaving the metro area: tucked away in Tappan, New York , just 40 minutes from Manhattan, sits The ’76 House — America’s oldest restaurant . Built in 1668 , the tavern predates the United States itself, making it one of the most storied dining destinations in the country . Though today it’s known for its Sunday brunches, candlelit dinners, and live music by the fire , this Revolutionary-era tavern was once the stage for one of the nation’s most dramatic spy stories . During the height of the war, The ’76 House served as the makeshift prison of Major John André , the British officer who conspired with Benedict Arnold to surrender West Point to the enemy. His capture — and eventual execution — shifted the course of the Revolution. The episode earned The ’76 House its lasting nickname: “America’s Spy Prison.” The tavern’s walls also hold memories of George Washington himself, who dined here alongside Continental generals and his provisioner Samuel Fraunces . Far from just a pitstop for soldiers, the inn became a hub of revolutionary planning, a gathering place for patriots, and a witness to history that could have easily unfolded differently. Of course, The ’76 House isn’t just a museum piece. Lovingly restored by the Norden family, the restaurant offers all the warmth of a historic inn — four glowing fireplaces, a garden patio, and a cozy porch perfect for sipping wine . Its acclaimed chef serves up hearty American fare like the famous Onion Soup Lafayette , a Berkshire pork chop glazed with Hudson Valley apple brandy , or a classic Yankee Pot Roast served with a popover. Mind you—all presented in a setting where centuries-old beams and flickering candles transport you to another era. On weekends, you’ll even find live music filling the tavern, keeping the centuries-old tradition of communal gathering alive. How to get there from NYC ----------------------------- 📍 The ’76 House is located at 110 Main Street in Tappan, NY. From Manhattan, it’s about a 40-minute drive up the Palisades Parkway. For those without a car, take NJ Transit’s Pascack Valley Line to Sparkill, then it’s a quick rideshare to the tavern. Source: https://secretnyc.co/americas-oldest-restaurant-the-76-house-tappan-ny/