New York’s Deadliest Dinner Party Is Coming To A Brooklyn Hotel: Three-Courses Served With A Thrilling Murder Mystery

A murder has occurred in New York —one which sounds like something straight out of an Agatha Christie novel. The murder has no witnesses, the charm of the characters is blinding, and, as per all great mysteries, it could have been anyone . At The Guilty Banquet in New York, you and your fellow diners will eat, drink, and become part of the [immersive experience](https://secretnyc.co/best-immersive-experiences-in-nyc/), deciding who’s behind the mystery by the night’s end. The Guilty Banquet: Masquerade Murder Mystery Dinner February 20, 2026 18:00 + more dates Arlo Williamsburg From $43.55 Buy tickets What is The Guilty Banquet? --------------------------- At The Guilty Banquet, a delicious three-course meal is served alongside a thrilling ‘whodunit?’.Expect a night which echoes Edgar Allan Poe’s “Murders in the Rue Morgue”, every glance concealing a clue and every whisper hinting at guilt. As you dine, gifted actors draw you into the story, playing characters you’ll love—but never fully trust. Discuss your theories with your table, and as the two-hour show plays out , only keen observers, like Poe’s detective, will discover the truth. Inside the murder mystery at The Arlo Williamsburg -------------------------------------------------- The Arlo Williamsburg Hotel sets the stage for a night of mystery and masquerade , with costumes and masks highly encouraged for diners who’d like to feel even more immersed in the mystery of it all.A three-course meal is available for purchase at the venue, with several options to choose from for each course. But diners be warned, the meal is tied to the murder. The menu can range from snapper carpaccio, to braised beef cheeks, and finished off by, perhaps, a pavlova with candied persimmons. The choice is yours, but don’t let the flavors distract you—each dish might hide a clue . As dinner ends and the story concludes, it’s over to you to name the guilty party. The Guilty Banquet: Masquerade Murder Mystery Dinner February 20, 2026 18:00 + more dates Arlo Williamsburg From $43.55 Buy tickets A murder at a banquet doesn’t happen every day—not even in New York. On selected dates , the Brooklyn hotel in Williamsburg transforms into a scene worthy of Agatha Christie herself: a lavish dinner laced with drama, intrigue, and culinary temptation. But beware—beneath the clinking glasses and glittering charm, suspicion simmers. Seats for this murderous feast are limited , so we urge all dining detectives to secure theirs swiftly. After all, only you can uncover where the truth hides among silverware. The Guilty Banquet: Masquerade Murder Mystery Dinner February 20, 2026 18:00 + more dates Arlo Williamsburg From $43.55 Buy tickets Source: https://secretnyc.co/the-guilty-banquet-nyc-murder-mystery-dinner-show/