NYC’s Century-Old Ice Cream Parlor Still Scoops Homemade Sundaes To Perfection

There’s a reason Eddie’s Sweet Shop has been around for 100 years. The **Queens** staple feels like a moment frozen in time, courtesy of its vintage charm: an inviting countertop with swivel stools, wooden walls, pressed tin ceilings, an antique register. But the oldest [ice cream parlor in NYC](https://secretnyc.co/best-ice-cream-shops-nyc/) is not only celebrating a triple-digit anniversary because of its aesthetics — its irresistible menu of homemade scoops catapulted the business into iconic territory. If you’ve yet to sample Eddie’s scoops , sundaes , and shakes , we highly suggest making a visit. Get the scoop on Eddie’s Sweet Shop ----------------------------------- Originally called Witt’s back in the 20s, the **dessert**-lovers’ paradise switched names the 1960s when the Citrano family stepped in. Currently, Vito Citrano is the one helming the business and keeping his family’s sweet tradition alive. The shop offers classics like chocolate , vanilla chip , and butter pecan, but also spices up the offerings with selections like maple walnut and pistachio pineapple . However, the main draw of Eddie’s sundaes is its syrups — cherry, lime, orange, Coke . Should you be feeling extra adventurous, you might want to inquire about the alleged secret menu. The offerings and nostalgia fuel customers of all ages to keep coming back for more, and every pitstop feels like a warm hug, which separates the Forest Hills shop from its counterparts. For a 2021 profile of Citrano and his business in *The New York Times*, Jolie Alonys, the owner of Thompson Chemists in Soho , spoke fondly about evenings at Eddie’s and her own family’s close-knit relationship with the sweet spot — the place where she met her husband. “I thought it was so romantic to sit at a small, round table set for two and share a banana split with coffee ice cream and chocolate syrup and homemade whipped cream,” she says. If we didn’t know better, we’d say that sounds like the perfect night out. Should you be craving a li’l something sweet and a feel-good environment, grab a (swivel) chair at Eddie’s and dig in. Explore the other great NYC spots also celebrating their centennials in 2025, like **Lexington Candy Shop**, **Argosy Booksellers**, and **Lombardi’s**. 📍 105-29 Metropolitan Ave, Forest Hills ☎️ 718-520-8514 ⏰ Sun, Wed, Thurs 3-10pm; Fri, Sat 3-11pm Source: https://secretnyc.co/eddies-sweet-shop-nycs-oldest-ice-cream-shop/