Kelly's Dockside Cafe — Restaurant in City of Ithaca

It's an interesting location, but I suggest you skip it. Part dank bar, part indoor restaurant, part outdoor waters edge dining. Service was friendly, but misleading. Prices are above average to ridiculous. Regarding the misleading service, the waitress who I suspect may have been the owner, made what felt like a kind offer for our 9 year old son, who inquired if he could get a cinnamon roll as a side with his eggs instead of toast. She told him yes, and acted kind of cutesy about it, encouraging him to get it. My wife and I were a little surprised but assumed it was someone being nice to a child, as does tend to happen. Nope, not it. She was just encouraging him to rack up the bill. To start, his 2 eggs cost 8.50. Yes, just 2 eggs!! No potatoes, no cheese, and apparently no toast either. Just 2 eggs on a plate. Then we were hit with $4 for the cinnamon roll. This honestly felt predatory, but we hadn't thoroughly investigated the details of his choices so we paid it. Turns out, even though the prices on the menu are plenty high enough for you to easily assume the cost represents platters, much of the menu is ala carte. I got a "jumbo bacon burger platter" that came with potato wedges. Thr burger was wholly unimpressive in quality, and not what I would call jumbo, but not small and a sufficient amount of food for $14.95. My wife got an omelet for $12, which again came with nothing. She ordered an english muffin, thinking it was included, but when it showed up late (omelet finished) and the waitress voluntarily made it "on the house", this clued us in to the fact it was an extra as well. The water tastes like it is coming directly out of the creek in back, so get yourself something else if you can. All in all, I am a value oriented person that is willing to pay for quality and/or quantity, but this place falls very short by massively overcharging for the quality or quantity they are serving. I don't see going back again, although the outdoor dining is a...

Kelly's Dockside Cafe is a hidden treasure in Ithaca, offering a perfect blend of lakeside charm, delicious food, and a laid-back atmosphere. Situated right on the water, this cozy café provides a relaxed setting to enjoy a meal while taking in the serene views of the surrounding natural beauty.

The menu at Kelly's Dockside Cafe is an inviting mix of classic American comfort food and seafood dishes, with something for everyone. One of the most popular dishes is their fish and chips, served with crispy batter and flaky fish that’s perfectly seasoned. The lobster roll is another standout, packed with fresh lobster meat and served on a buttery, toasted bun—simple yet indulgent. For those looking for a lighter option, the Caesar salad with grilled chicken or shrimp is always fresh and satisfying.

The café also offers a fantastic selection of drinks, including local craft beers, wines, and refreshing cocktails. The Moscow mule is a favorite, served with a nice balance of ginger and lime. Pair it with some fresh seafood or a juicy burger, and you're set for a relaxing and delicious meal.

What makes Kelly's Dockside Cafe even more special is its scenic lakeside location. Whether you're dining inside with its casual, nautical-themed decor or enjoying the outdoor seating area, the views are always stunning. The outdoor deck, especially on a warm evening, is the perfect place to sip on a drink and watch the boats go by.

The staff at Kelly's Dockside Cafe is friendly and attentive, making sure guests feel right at home. The service is prompt, and the overall vibe is relaxed yet lively, ideal for both casual lunches and evening dinners with friends or family.

If you're in Ithaca and looking for a place to enjoy delicious food with a stunning view, Kelly's Dockside Cafe is a must-visit. Whether you're a seafood lover or just in the mood for a classic American meal, this charming lakeside café is sure to deliver a memorable...

Went with my girlfriend when looking for something to eat relatively late (about 8:30 pm). Upon entering, the inside was unbearably humid. A man who turned out to be the cook for the night (or so it appeared) greeted us at the door to seat us, forehead dripping with sweat. On our way back to the deck, we noticed a chair propping the singular bathroom door open next to an industrial fan. Yes, there's one bathroom. Only one other party was eating besides us, which was sort of a red flag to me. The deck was poorly lit. Plates and cups were already placed, which didn't appeal to me as it was outside in the summer near an inlet. Spider webs littered the dinning area and surrounding vegetation. Tables weren't covered, exposing a bare, rusty, "mesh", metal surface - not ideal for dining establishment. While waiting for our food, a patron from the bar up front, stumbled out to the deck and, completely unaware of our presence a mere 40 ft away, began urinating off the deck, along the side where the kitchen leads to the outside. In terms of the food, albeit being reluctant to eat: my salmon was tasty; fried calamari was properly fried; my girlfriend enjoyed her battered fish sandwich; however, the "breadstick" with my side salad was nothing more than a toasted hot dog bun... In all, I felt bad for the place - Potential is there. The man who was serving us appeared to have also been the cook, so obviously there's staffing issues. The patrons at the bar (4) gave off the impression that they are the regular business and probably don't help in creating a welcoming environment. The building appears old, and along with the lighting, gives off a dingy feel. It's apparent the owner needs to re-think his business model and consider some aesthetic changes, to start... If he cares. I...