HTML SitemapExplore
logo
Find Things to DoFind The Best Restaurants

Holy Cow Burgers — Restaurant in New York

Name
Holy Cow Burgers
Description
Nearby attractions
Max Adventures Kids Birthday Party Place
2378 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Lenape Playground
3802 Avenue U #5108, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Sunglass Hut
5100 Kings Plz #0130A, Brooklyn, NY 11234
El Caribe Country Club Caterers
5945 Strickland Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Marine Park Salt Marsh Nature Trail
Marine Park Salt Marsh Nature Center, 3301 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Hendrick I. Lott House
1940 E 36th St, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Salt Marsh Nature Center
3301 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Wheel Fun Rentals | Marine Park
Avenue U &, E 33rd St, Brooklyn, NY 11229
NY I GREEN LLC Artificial Turf
2225 E 59th Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Nearby restaurants
Plaza King Coffee Shop
5117 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Guacado Mexican Grill
5119-A Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Wonder Flatlands
2401 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Noor BBQ and Grill
5119 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Shake Shack Kings Plaza
Floor 1, Kings Plaza Shopping Center, 5100 Kings Plz, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Y&Y Sushi
2368 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Brooklyn Beef N’ Cheese
5409 Avenue T, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Yong Kang Street
2, 5100 Kings Plz, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Sbarro
2509 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Floridian Plaza Diner
2301 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11234
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
Holy Cow Burgers tourism.Holy Cow Burgers hotels.Holy Cow Burgers bed and breakfast. flights to Holy Cow Burgers.Holy Cow Burgers attractions.Holy Cow Burgers restaurants.Holy Cow Burgers travel.Holy Cow Burgers travel guide.Holy Cow Burgers travel blog.Holy Cow Burgers pictures.Holy Cow Burgers photos.Holy Cow Burgers travel tips.Holy Cow Burgers maps.Holy Cow Burgers things to do.
Holy Cow Burgers things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Holy Cow Burgers
United StatesNew YorkNew YorkHoly Cow Burgers

Basic Info

Holy Cow Burgers

4113 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11234
4.7(333)$$$$
Open until 2:00 AM
order
order
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

attractions: Max Adventures Kids Birthday Party Place, Lenape Playground, Sunglass Hut, El Caribe Country Club Caterers, Marine Park Salt Marsh Nature Trail, Hendrick I. Lott House, Salt Marsh Nature Center, Wheel Fun Rentals | Marine Park, NY I GREEN LLC Artificial Turf, restaurants: Plaza King Coffee Shop, Guacado Mexican Grill, Wonder Flatlands, Noor BBQ and Grill, Shake Shack Kings Plaza, Y&Y Sushi, Brooklyn Beef N’ Cheese, Yong Kang Street, Sbarro, Floridian Plaza Diner
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(718) 734-2540
Website
holycow.nyc
Open hoursSee all hours
Wed10 AM - 2 AMOpen

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in New York
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in New York
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in New York
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
TENDERS
dish
HOLY CHICKEN
dish
CLASSIC BURGER
dish
HOLY BURGER
dish
HOLY DOG
dish
DOUBLE SMASHED ONION HOLY BURGER
dish
CHOPPED CHEESE
dish
N.Y.C. CHEESESTEAK
dish
BACON EGG & CHEESE
dish
GRILLED CHICKEN CLUB SANDWICH
dish
CHICKEN CHOPPED CHEESE
dish
TAIWANESE CHICKEN NUGGETS
dish
BEEF SLIDERS
dish
CHICKEN SLIDERS
dish
CHOPPED CHEESE SLIDERS
dish
CHICKEN CHOPPED CHEESE SLIDERS
dish
SLIDERS DOUBLE SMASH WITH BACON JALAPENO
dish
MIX & MATCH SLIDERS
dish
SEASONED FRIES
dish
CHEESE FRIES
dish
ONION RINGS
dish
SWEET POTATO TOTS
dish
CHICKEN NUGGETS
dish
LOADED FRIES
dish
MOZZARELLA STICKS
dish
WATER
dish
SODA
dish
$1.50 SODA CAN
dish
JUICE
dish
RED BULL
dish
COOKIES
dish
BROWNIE
dish
ICE-CREAM SCOOP
dish
MILK-SHAKE
dish
TURKEY SANDWICH
dish
ROAST BEEF SANDWICH
dish
CLUB SUPREME SANDWICH
dish
TURKEY SLICED
dish
3 FT TURKEY SUB ( 4 HR PRIOR NOTICE FOR ORDER)
dish
PLANT-BASED CHICKEN WRAP
dish
PLANT-BASED BURGER
dish
PLANT-BASED CHICKEN SANDWICH
dish
PLANT-BASED CHOPPED CHEESE
dish
PLANT BASED LOADED FRIES
dish
PLANT-BASED HOTDOG
dish
PLANT-BASED CHICKEN NUGGETS
dish
PLANT-BASED TENDERS
dish
PLANT-BASED BEEF SLIDERS
dish
PLANT-BASED CHICKEN SLIDERS
dish
PLANT-BASED MIX & MATCH SLIDERS
dish
PLANT-BASED CHOPPED CHEESE SLIDERS
dish
PLANT-BASED TURKEY SANDWICH
dish
PLANT BASED CHICKEN CHOPPED CHEESE
dish
PLANT BASED SLIDER BY THE BOX
dish
PLANT BASED 6FT TURKEY SUB (4 HR PRIOR NOTICE FOR ORDER)
dish
GLUTEN -FREE HOLY DOG
dish
GLUTEN-FREE HOLY TENDERS
dish
GLUTEN - FREE HOLY CHICKEN
dish
GLUTEN - FREE CLASSIC BURGER
dish
GLUTEN-FREE C HOLY BURGER
dish
GLUTEN-FREE DOUBLE SMASHED ONION HOLY BURGER
dish
GLUTEN-FREE CHOPPED CHEESE
dish
GLUTEN-FREE N.Y.C CHEESESTEAK
dish
GLUTEN FREE GRILLED CHICKEN CLUB SANDWICH
dish
GLUTEN-FREE CHICKEN NUGGETS
dish
GLUTEN FREE TURKEY SANDWICH
dish
GLUTEN-FREE ROAST BEEF SANDWICH
dish
GLUTEN FREE PLANT-BASED BURGER
dish
GLUTEN FREEF PLANT-BASED CHOPPED CHEESE
dish
GLUTEN FREE COOKIE
dish
CHICKEN WRAP
dish
COMBO MEAL
dish
NUGGETS COMBO
dish
HALF TURKEY COMBO
dish
HALF ROAST BEEF COMBO
dish
RED BULL LUNCH SPECIAL
dish
HOLY SAMPLER
dish
HOLY SLIDERS SAMPLER
dish
TWO CHICKEN WRAP COMBO
dish
HOLY COW FAMILY BOX (FOR 4-PERSON)
dish
HOLY COW FAMILY BOX (FOR 6-PERSON)
dish
SIDES BY THE BOX
dish
SLIDERS BY THE BOX
dish
VEGAN SLIDERS BY THE BOX
dish
DELI SUB BY THE BOX
dish
PROTEIN GRILLED CHICKEN
dish
HOLY SAUCE
dish
PERI-PERI
dish
VEGAN
dish
CHEESE SAUCE
dish
BBQ

Reviews

Nearby attractions of Holy Cow Burgers

Max Adventures Kids Birthday Party Place

Lenape Playground

Sunglass Hut

El Caribe Country Club Caterers

Marine Park Salt Marsh Nature Trail

Hendrick I. Lott House

Salt Marsh Nature Center

Wheel Fun Rentals | Marine Park

NY I GREEN LLC Artificial Turf

Max Adventures Kids Birthday Party Place

Max Adventures Kids Birthday Party Place

4.8

(440)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Lenape Playground

Lenape Playground

4.3

(157)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
Sunglass Hut

Sunglass Hut

3.1

(27)

Open 24 hours
Click for details
El Caribe Country Club Caterers

El Caribe Country Club Caterers

4.6

(491)

Open until 8:00 PM
Click for details

Things to do nearby

The Full-Day See It All NYC Tour
The Full-Day See It All NYC Tour
Wed, Dec 10 • 10:30 AM
New York, New York, 10019
View details
Underground Harlem Jazz Tour
Underground Harlem Jazz Tour
Wed, Dec 10 • 6:00 PM
New York, New York, 10027
View details
Private photohsoot in NYC by Lorena
Private photohsoot in NYC by Lorena
Wed, Dec 10 • 2:00 PM
The Bronx, New York, 10462
View details

Nearby restaurants of Holy Cow Burgers

Plaza King Coffee Shop

Guacado Mexican Grill

Wonder Flatlands

Noor BBQ and Grill

Shake Shack Kings Plaza

Y&Y Sushi

Brooklyn Beef N’ Cheese

Yong Kang Street

Sbarro

Floridian Plaza Diner

Plaza King Coffee Shop

Plaza King Coffee Shop

4.3

(132)

Click for details
Guacado Mexican Grill

Guacado Mexican Grill

4.7

(86)

Click for details
Wonder Flatlands

Wonder Flatlands

5.0

(1)

Click for details
Noor BBQ and Grill

Noor BBQ and Grill

4.8

(43)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

Š 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.
logo

Posts

Nikolay KNikolay K
Disappointing Experience at Holy Caw Sunday night… and the family is craving a good burger. You know that feeling. Who better to trust than Google? With a 4.8-star rating, we decided to make a detour off the highway, adjusting our navigation to find "Holy Caw", located at 4113 Avenue U, Brooklyn. Parking? No problem—there was plenty of street parking available. Upon walking in, the first impression was disappointing. The place wasn’t as clean as one would expect from a restaurant. Still, the staff was very friendly and helped us place an order for two Holy Burgers with a side of french fries, along with a medium-sized onion rings. We opted for takeout. Payment: They accept credit cards, but be aware that there’s a 3% surcharge for card payments. Now, onto the food. Portions? Generous. The burger was large, and the french fries portion was big enough for two adults. Taste? Unfortunately, this is where things went downhill. I ordered my burger medium-rare, but what I received was a flat, dry, and uninspiring patty. The dressing inside the burger had an unusual taste, which seemed out of place—maybe it was meant to mask the dryness of the meat. To make matters worse, the ketchup provided was watered down and had no real flavor. Given the hype and high rating, I expected much better. I honestly feel bad for those who rated this place 4.8 stars—it just didn’t live up to expectations. Would I return? Probably not.
Adrian CoardAdrian Coard
Floor & table were dirty. May have been because the two man crew seemed really busy. Host stated he was about to clean tables when my wife and I arrived at 6:30 pm on Saturday. Ambiance was nice with a nice booth in front of store. Food was well prepared and nicely presented. Portions were large and filling. I had a Philly cheesesteak with onion rings, and my wife had the chicken fingers with cheesy fries. There was enough food that we actually took some home. Decor was really Nice with two beautiful murals on the wall one saying holy cow and the other one giving me the location as Marine Park. Menu was interesting and my wife and I will return another time. Overall, a nice experience worth a second visit
Kollier :3Kollier :3
Kinda pricey but actually worth it i swear! You're better off getting from here rather than shake shack in the mall if you want a better quality burger. Like i said, pricey as toppings are at least $2 and up but i recommend getting a fried egg on the burger! The Holy cow burger is absolutely amaaazing 🙀! Its a rib and brisket patty blend and its $12 for cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, definitely worth it 👍🏽 Pretty empty majority of the time and theres only one booth and a few tables. Just one burger is pricey so id avoid anything else unless you really want it but i highly recommend this place! Also halal and have veggie options too! The employees are nice :)
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in New York

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Disappointing Experience at Holy Caw Sunday night… and the family is craving a good burger. You know that feeling. Who better to trust than Google? With a 4.8-star rating, we decided to make a detour off the highway, adjusting our navigation to find "Holy Caw", located at 4113 Avenue U, Brooklyn. Parking? No problem—there was plenty of street parking available. Upon walking in, the first impression was disappointing. The place wasn’t as clean as one would expect from a restaurant. Still, the staff was very friendly and helped us place an order for two Holy Burgers with a side of french fries, along with a medium-sized onion rings. We opted for takeout. Payment: They accept credit cards, but be aware that there’s a 3% surcharge for card payments. Now, onto the food. Portions? Generous. The burger was large, and the french fries portion was big enough for two adults. Taste? Unfortunately, this is where things went downhill. I ordered my burger medium-rare, but what I received was a flat, dry, and uninspiring patty. The dressing inside the burger had an unusual taste, which seemed out of place—maybe it was meant to mask the dryness of the meat. To make matters worse, the ketchup provided was watered down and had no real flavor. Given the hype and high rating, I expected much better. I honestly feel bad for those who rated this place 4.8 stars—it just didn’t live up to expectations. Would I return? Probably not.
Nikolay K

Nikolay K

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in New York

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Floor & table were dirty. May have been because the two man crew seemed really busy. Host stated he was about to clean tables when my wife and I arrived at 6:30 pm on Saturday. Ambiance was nice with a nice booth in front of store. Food was well prepared and nicely presented. Portions were large and filling. I had a Philly cheesesteak with onion rings, and my wife had the chicken fingers with cheesy fries. There was enough food that we actually took some home. Decor was really Nice with two beautiful murals on the wall one saying holy cow and the other one giving me the location as Marine Park. Menu was interesting and my wife and I will return another time. Overall, a nice experience worth a second visit
Adrian Coard

Adrian Coard

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in New York

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Kinda pricey but actually worth it i swear! You're better off getting from here rather than shake shack in the mall if you want a better quality burger. Like i said, pricey as toppings are at least $2 and up but i recommend getting a fried egg on the burger! The Holy cow burger is absolutely amaaazing 🙀! Its a rib and brisket patty blend and its $12 for cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, definitely worth it 👍🏽 Pretty empty majority of the time and theres only one booth and a few tables. Just one burger is pricey so id avoid anything else unless you really want it but i highly recommend this place! Also halal and have veggie options too! The employees are nice :)
Kollier :3

Kollier :3

See more posts
See more posts

Reviews of Holy Cow Burgers

4.7
(333)
avatar
1.0
1y

I visited HolyCow on June 27th. Notice shortly after that the cashier that took my order was also the cook, he walked away to the back. Was only seeing one person through the door walking back and forth. He did not wash his hands or had gloves on. I was looking at him how he was rushing to prepare my chicken sandwich and fries. Waited for almost 30 minutes, there was only one couple ahead of me. And 2 other tables were occupied with people eating. When he brought me my meal Finally!!! the bag was stapled so I opened it to see what he put in there because this was my 1st time visiting the joint. No Napkins, just the chicken sandwich and very greasy fries. I took the fries out and told him, I cannot eat this. It's too greasy and and burnt he answered me by telling me I needed to wait 48 hours to get a refund. I told him 48 hours, I did pay cash and you did not provide me my receipt. So this other dude stepped in and was trying to figure out how to print the receipt out. Meanwhile I see the 1st guy that took my order and prepare my meal walk to the back and throw the fries back into the batch of other fries sitting there. I mean after I took those fries out of the bag it should of been trash but he was planning to sell those fries to someone else. NASTY!!! Not to mentioned waited an additional 10 minutes for the receipt and my money back. Also I paid for a drink and I had to remind him where my drink that I paid for. And he charged me an extra 3 dollars for one slice of cheese on my sandwich. Geez...Inflation is killing us. One only good thing I could say that the guy was nice. That's it. I will never go back though. They are unsanitary. I rather drive out of my way to BurgerFi on 86th Street. The burgers there are grass-fed and there chicken steriod free. And definitely the food 100% way tastier and healthier.**

*Response to owner:Thank you for replying back, even if you make the changes. It's a thing for me and the public we want things done right the 1st time. I could gotten sick if you would of given me a bacteria from not washing your hands. The prices are over the roof when buying fast food. We do not need to get sick as well. Clean up your act, hopefully your business would become successful in the future. But unfortunately I feel safer and have peace of mind going to my usual place on...

   Read more
avatar
3.0
42w

Disappointing Experience at Holy Caw

Sunday night… and the family is craving a good burger. You know that feeling. Who better to trust than Google? With a 4.8-star rating, we decided to make a detour off the highway, adjusting our navigation to find "Holy Caw", located at 4113 Avenue U, Brooklyn.

Parking? No problem—there was plenty of street parking available.

Upon walking in, the first impression was disappointing. The place wasn’t as clean as one would expect from a restaurant. Still, the staff was very friendly and helped us place an order for two Holy Burgers with a side of french fries, along with a medium-sized onion rings. We opted for takeout.

Payment: They accept credit cards, but be aware that there’s a 3% surcharge for card payments.

Now, onto the food. Portions? Generous. The burger was large, and the french fries portion was big enough for two adults.

Taste? Unfortunately, this is where things went downhill. I ordered my burger medium-rare, but what I received was a flat, dry, and uninspiring patty. The dressing inside the burger had an unusual taste, which seemed out of place—maybe it was meant to mask the dryness of the meat. To make matters worse, the ketchup provided was watered down and had no real flavor.

Given the hype and high rating, I expected much better. I honestly feel bad for those who rated this place 4.8 stars—it just didn’t live up to expectations.

Would I return?...

   Read more
avatar
2.0
22w

I don’t normally leave reviews, but this experience really stood out — for all the wrong reasons. When I walked in, I was shocked to find that there was only one employee running the entire restaurant — taking orders, cooking, and managing everything by himself. Because of that, I ended up waiting over 45 minutes just to get my food.

To be clear, the person working behind the counter was doing the absolute best they could under the circumstances and deserves serious credit. Honestly, whoever owns this place should be ashamed for leaving one person to run the entire operation alone, and they absolutely need to hire more staff. That employee deserves a raise just for holding the place together.

Now for the other issue — the restaurant itself looked and smelled terrible. The whole place gave off a neglected, almost abandoned vibe. The most off-putting thing? There was an actual spider web stretching from the ceiling lamp to the cookie counter. That’s just unacceptable.

Until they clean the place up and hire more people, I wouldn’t...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next