Cindy's Pizza *** DELIVERY ONLY*** NO PICKUP — Restaurant in Stillwater

Since I had to give, at least, 1 star, I have it 1 star. I was trying to order some food, on Sunday, but couldn't pick it up, until Tuesday (what the site said). I ordered anyway, but the school called, on Tuesday morning, telling me my daughter had a fever and I needed to pick her up. I was supposed to pick the pizza up at 4:35 pm, but forgot, due to having a sick child at home. Since they don't open until 4, I kept forgetting to call and cancel. I called, today, and Cindy was being extremely rude. She said she went in, on Sunday, to make the food (even though it wasn't scheduled until Tuesday). Then, she said she made it, again, on Tuesday. She said she put in a lot of effort. I didn't tell her to make it on Sunday. I just told her to keep the money...

I ordered two pizzas and on one of them the cheese was a little off as one of the chefs must have pulled it off the oven a little too quickly. Well they gave me the whole pizza for free. And Cindy was very nice about it. Apart from that, the food speaks for itself. It's a little pricey but better than pizzahut or papa johns. Probably about equal with hideaway. I recommend getting a 20 inch pizza with two toppings, like sausage and mushroom, and an order of cinnamon knobs. The only negative I can say is that it's in a weird location and it's not a restaurant you can eat in. Since you're picking up the pizza that doesn't matter too much. Please support local businesses over...

Always delicious pizzas and Cindy continues to create new desserts as well as pizzas! What more could you ask for from a passionate chef?! We had an isolated issue where we called pizza into the Stillwater location and when we arrived to pick it up, there was no record of the order or call despite verifying the time, date, and phone number. The miscommunication was rectified and we continue to order amazing pizza and drool over the pies she creates when we don’t order. Recommend to all who enjoy a great...