If you want mediocrity to be the hallmark of your celebration, look no further. We placed an order for a package deal of birthday cake, cupcakes and cake pops a couple of months in advance for our daughter's 1st birthday but were profoundly disappointed by the products we received. The icing/decoration on the cake as well as the cupcakes was unimaginative. They simply made it as per the inspiration picture we sent. We had asked them to use their imagination and surprise us, but that request was clearly ignored. The cake wasn't fluffy, the texture was lumpy to be precise. The same goes for the cupcakes and cake pops. All of it tasted extremely soapy and unappetizing because of the excessive use of baking soda. The kids and adults hated it alike and all the cake pieces ended up in the trash bin. It was a 2-tier cake and the bottom tier of the cake remained untouched as the guests told each other to avoid the soapy cake. It was promptly trashed because of the horrible taste. We trusted Willow & Olivia to live up to their reputation in West Orange, to make our special occasion a fond memory, but instead we were thoroughly let down and would always remember them for the lumpy, soapy unpalatable cake that ruined our daughter's first birthday. For the premium they charge, the end products are subpar. Spare yourself the horror and steer clear of this establishment if you don't want to be deeply disappointed.