Punta Fenaio
Beautifully renovated, comfortable small boutique hotel attached to an almost 150 year old lighthouse in a remote location on Isola de Giglio (Giglio Island). Simply put, this is a unique and magical place. Worth the effort to find it, book it and get there.
The hotel is owned and operated by a charming Italian couple, Paola and Mario with a small staff of kind local young people. Everyone sweetly tried their best with English and with my limited Italian we made it work, but there were only a couple of competent English speakers. Other than us, guests were 100% Italian.
You must coordinate the transfer with the hotel as only ATV or Jeep 4x4 can manage the very rocky rugged dirt road (about a mile or more) that goes through a nature reserve. Once at the hotel, all your meals are a la carte at the hotel since it’s remote.
There isn’t very much to do at the hotel but we didn’t mind at all. You can explore the area hiking, swimming down in the sea, lounging in the sun and eating. We were there in August and it was hot, so we only wanted to lounge in shade. It was too hot for us to go hiking. We swam in the sea, the water was great. It was a little rough so we stayed close to the ladder. Loved it.
Our room was spacious, spotless and well appointed with a large modern bathroom, including a nice rain shower. We were on the second floor with a big terrace overlooking the sea. Fantastic!! Good bed and pillows, good air conditioning for the hot days.
The food was mostly quite tasty. You can get 3 meals per day, which we did, but in retrospect I would have been fine with just breakfast and dinner. There’s a selection of wines available and if you don’t finish a bottle they offer to hold it for you to finish the next day.
A couple of minor observations to encourage improvement. The dinner service was really slow and long spacing between courses was a problem. The staff apologized but I think they can improve on it. We enjoyed the beautiful evening overlooking the sea but this timing should be fixed. Also, some of the food came out lukewarm. Maybe use covers on the dishes since it’s windy and a bit of a walk to the tables. Finally, I think the ladder into the sea could be better built and maintained, the wood steps were slippery with algae (scrub with a brush), a little tricky. The nice smart tv in the room couldn’t play anything. We tried for a while but couldn’t get anything, didn’t ask for help but maybe include some information about it. Last thing, guys your customers like to use American Express. I know it costs the merchant a little more but you will find you get more affluent customers...
Read moreThe most important comment to make about this hotel is what an achievement it is. Isolated completely from roads and inaccessible by car is the most divine food, wine, service and incredible view and it is exceptional. Not even mentioning the experience of staying in a lighthouse!|Perhaps for us wimpy English, the trek/climb to reach it was a little daunting - and I think it should be made clear this is not for visitors with any physical impairment as there is a very steep climb together with a jarring quad-bike trip to get or leave the hotel .. but then again, there is also nothing like it. |Mario and Paula were accommodating on every single occasion we asked and, as we were unaware we couldn’t reach the hotel by taxi/hire car, were more than happy to fetch and deliver us to where the road ended - but we did feel horribly guilty knowing that they were also on service at breakfast so I’m afraid we did feel restricted as to how late we could stay out. (Our own restrictions I must add- not theirs!) The restaurant service was equally as accommodating, an exciting and extravagant menu accompanied by delicious wines. Did I mention the view…. !||Beautiful, stunning, exemplary but please understand location. (Boat taxi to a nearby beach is...
Read moreThe most important comment to make about this hotel is what an achievement it is. Isolated completely from roads and inaccessible by car is the most divine food, wine, service and incredible view and it is exceptional. Not even mentioning the experience of staying in a lighthouse!|Perhaps for us wimpy English, the trek/climb to reach it was a little daunting - and I think it should be made clear this is not for visitors with any physical impairment as there is a very steep climb together with a jarring quad-bike trip to get or leave the hotel .. but then again, there is also nothing like it. |Mario and Paula were accommodating on every single occasion we asked and, as we were unaware we couldn’t reach the hotel by taxi/hire car, were more than happy to fetch and deliver us to where the road ended - but we did feel horribly guilty knowing that they were also on service at breakfast so I’m afraid we did feel restricted as to how late we could stay out. (Our own restrictions I must add- not theirs!) The restaurant service was equally as accommodating, an exciting and extravagant menu accompanied by delicious wines. Did I mention the view…. !||Beautiful, stunning, exemplary but please understand location. (Boat taxi to a nearby beach is...
Read more