Newtown Farm Market — Local services in Anderson Township

Hidden away amongst ball fields and landscaping companies, Newtown Farm Market is a treasure most stumble upon without intentionally seeking it out.

Rustic charm and simple hand written signage harken back to simpler days when your neighbors grew or raised the food you eat. The displays are always need and organized, the selection of produce, sundry items, baked goods, and proteins have roots within the local area and Ohio’s vast network of quality producers. From juicy tart apples fresh off the orchard trees, to beautiful squash, ripened tomatoes, and gorgeous peppers out of local fields, NFM makes sure only the best quality produce is on display.

The back wall hosts racks of fresh breads, cookies, pies and other baked goods that I have yet to be disappointed by.

There are locally sourced jams, jellies, pickled items, and sauces available.

An island oasis of bulk candies catch the gaze of those with a sweet tooth and a modest collection of local brews and distilled products add some adult options to your purchases.

EVERY TIME I am in NFM the staff greats me with a smile and does not just recite the line “anything I can help you find?”. They ACTUALLY want to help make your shopping trip successful.

Friendly, courteous, and helpful service is the key to quality retail experiences and NFM has that down.

If you have not already, add the NFM to your list of east side grocery stops. I can assure you that you will not drive away...

UPDATE: I don't know what has happened but the last two trips have been terrible. Last time stale baked goods and a snotty employee. This time rotten moldy tomatoes and attempted to buy the sugar baby watermelon that was advertised. The unknowledgeable employee pointed to a different type of melon and said they were sugar babies. Then went to get a frozen custard. Was charged full price for two that were less than half full. I think I'm done shopping here this is really sad. I truly loved this store and am so disappointed how things have been recently. Please do better. Keeping my old review for comparison...

Love how fresh the produce is, prices are great. Have fresh Amish baked goods delicious ice cream . I just wish they were open a little later in the summer. With my work schedule it is hard to get here during their business hours. Even staying open til 7 would be awesome. Headed home to enjoy my peaches n cream sweet corn...

If you haven’t been - make the trip! Newtown Farm Market exemplifies everything there is to love about shopping a locally owned business. Service, selection, unique finds and convenience! They have everything from ready made meals to produce and plants…and if they don’t have what you want, just ask! I am a Southern transplant who has longed to make boiled peanuts for years (if you know, you know), but finding raw peanuts locally that aren’t overly dry has led to many dead end searches. Upon asking if Newtown carried them, I was told that they didn’t, but they would look to see if they could find a source for them. A few days later, I was surprised to learn that they were able to find them, and would be getting them in the next week. Amazing, personal service that is so hard to find these days does actually still exist!! Thanks Nick and Jill for making Newtown Farm Market such a gem in...