Pfeiffer Station General Store — Local services in Dudley Township

Have stopped in a handful of times while visiting family in the area. Always like to patronize local shops. Loved all of the selection they have in one place. Especially liked the bulk spices. Very cute store. Noticed the last couple times I’ve stopped in though that things seem to be slipping. The Amish cakes and cookies have not looked the greatest (VERY dark-like burnt). I decided not to buy an Angel food cake because they were so burnt looking. I did get some chocolate chip cookies because my husband wanted some. That was a mistake. They were so hard nobody wanted to eat them. I like a crunchy chocolate chip cookie - but these were well beyond that. And the two fry pies we got out of the case - didn’t look to close at them before I bagged them - but noticed when I got home and we went to try them they had mold on them 🤢 must not be turning them over often enough. Although I love the convenience of it all at one shop, will probably just take the time to goto individual Amish spots to get things...

It's like returning to the Little House on the prairie; abundance of classic candy in glass jars to choose from. Meats cheeses, ice cream, Amish baked goods, specialty jams and jellies. If you want nostalgia this is where you go. The pizza is amazing and the lunch specials are delicious and...

Very cute on the inside, and a lot of choices for fun candies. But I felt like I was getting looked at weird by the person running the store. But when I introduced myself she seemed to become a lot more relaxed. Overall, this place is cool and...