Stoltzfus Butcher Shop — Local services in Lamar Township

For meat counter purchases, I'm sure this place is fine.

But for beef butchering, I would not recommend. I've dealt with them multiple times and had several mistakes. I've included specific instructions on my order, spoke to employees and the owner before processing. I asked for soup bones and they threw all the bones away. Then offered to give me someone else's beef bones. Steaks were irregularly cut. Chipped steak was cut too thick. Chunks of fat in the ground beef. It is very disappointing to raise an animal and then have your order "butchered" by the butcher. I've given them multiple chances and won't be back.

Two stars because the owner is very nice, but it doesn't make up for...

Good place for good meats and other Amish canned goods. Not a big place, but very nice people and a nice selection of fresh and frozen. We dropped off a deer for processing. The prices are fairly reasonable. If using deer processing services, be sure to check their Facebook for updates, as when they get a backlog, they sometimes stop accepting them whole. It's a long drive for us, but worth it. Attaching photo of 2023 deer processing pricing.

Update: picked up our deer today. Couldn't be more happy! Everything was packaged beautifully and the jalapeño cheese meat sticks are absolutely delicious!...

Amish owned and operated butcher shop. You can taste a difference between their meat and grocery store meat. Much more superior. And you'll never see meat at these prices or their exceptional customer service in a grocery store! 18 New York strip steaks, 12 very large chicken breasts( like a lb. a piece) 10 lbs of hamburger 1 lb of dried beef 2 lbs. of teriyaki beef Jerry 1 big bag of homemade potato chips 4 large homemade Easter eggs. (Raspberry and...