Maguire Store — Local services in Slaughterville

I was pleasantly surprised by how broad the selection of groceries they have to offer. All their baked goods I've had the pleasure to have are made by the owner(s) and have been delicious. They have cold cuts provided by the deli, limited selection of fresh veggies (which is good; smaller quantity means recent restocking which equals fresher availability), I haven't had their pizzas but the fact that EVERYTIME I'm in there, there's been atleast 3 pizza orders being picked up which can only mean they're making em' good and from what I've seen, they're generous in size and loaded with toppings. I must also note that all interactions with every member of their staff has been pleasant, ALL of which are kind, helpful, hardworking and humble. I certainly am thankful for...

Below is my original review... not true any more. Went to get pizza was told 40 minutes. I got there and the boxes were cold and i was charged 27.73 for two large pepperoni pizzas. .... just the two pizzas. It was over cooked cold and loaded with grease. I swear I have had better frozen pizza. Sorry to say this place has taken a dive and have now lost all my business..

No longer accurate...... It's a nice little convenience store kinda out in the middle of no where. I went in looking for Dimond dog food (witch they don't sell) but OMG I walked out with the most amazing pizza. Loaded down and great prices. I so would have been like everyone else in noble/slaughtervill and kept this gem under my hat but it's too good not...

Update: 2 stars went up to a 5. The owner made this right and I appreciate it so much! I wasn't expecting anything and they have such great customer service. Thank you!!

The pizza here is normally so good but last night, June 7th, 2025, was so not good. The crust had a weird taste and the cheese was not good. The older woman taking the order got the whole order wrong but my husband didn't want to stay 30 mins for the right order because we had a event to get too. I wish the woman that got to order wrong would have given us a discount coupon...