Cudlin's Meat Market — Local services in Town of Newfield

As a business owner with decades of experience sourcing premium products across the country, I can confidently say that Cudlin’s Meat Market, located just outside Ithaca in Newfield, NY, is one of the finest butcher shops in the United States.

John and Tim are not just butchers — they are true artisans of their craft. Their depth of knowledge, precision, and pride in their work are immediately evident. They don't just cut meat — they understand it. They prepare it as if they were feeding their own families, because in many cases, they are. They eat what they cut, and that speaks volumes about their commitment to quality and integrity.

From expertly trimmed steaks and chops to responsibly sourced Beef and pork, every cut at Cudlin’s is top-tier — clean, fresh, and deeply flavorful. The shop is immaculately maintained, and the customer service is second to none. John and Tim know their customers by name. They remember your preferences. They often have a bone ready for my dog before I even ask. That level of attentiveness is rare.

Unlike many high-end butcher shops across the country — including some of the most recognized names in New York City, Chicago, and San Francisco — Cudlin’s does not ship. That’s intentional. Their quality is best experienced in person, and it’s well worth the trip. It’s a destination for those who value craftsmanship, authenticity, and community.

In a market saturated with mass-produced, impersonal options, Cudlin’s Meat Market remains proudly independent, deeply local, and uncompromising in quality. Whether you're a chef, a serious home cook, or simply someone who values food that’s raised and cut with care, this is the butcher you’ve been looking for.

Cudlin’s doesn’t rely on trends or shipping boxes. They rely on reputation, relationships, and remarkable quality. And for that, they’ve earned my highest...

The best and real butcher place around Ithaca/Newfield/Enfield. Very honest people operating a small business place. Highly recommend to support as best as anyone can if you love ethically treated and processed super high quality beef, goat and pork. Both co-owners and operators treat me as an extended family with THE BEST customer service oriented attitudes. Note that Cudlin's is not your average or a "fake" butcher place claimed to be a butcher place but sell packed meats. Cudlin's is a real deal. They only buy the best quality and ethically raised livestock for...

I visited Cudlin's recently and my experience was exceptional. Highly recommend these two driven, knowledgeable individuals. The establishment was very clean and sanitary. They took care of me very well and provided me with exactly what I was looking for. The quality of meat is 100 percent. Definitly will be visiting these guys often. Don't need to go too far or spend crazy amount of money for quality meat when we have it...