Schutt's Apple Mill — Local services in Town of Penfield

Love this country store. It's getting too popular; it gets crowded. But this place offers much. The best apple cider & fried cakes!!! So much more. A Webster, NY gem! 100% worth a trip if you visit Rochester, NY! Please sell your fried cakes & apple cider at the new Village Bakery in Webster's village! I just bought Relic in their tasting room on may 3rd, 2019. Tastes like champagne! Love my new tee shirts & the donuts, + cider! I enjoy buying gifts from Schutt's to give to friends and family. I would not buy the logo products if they did not include, Webster, N.Y. on them, so thank you for that! I grew up around the corner from Schutt's, & we locals claim the area as Webster! I live in San Francisco now but love coming home & enjoying the old fashioned wonderments at Schutt's and other locally owned shops. Shopping local helps local families stay put. I always buy gifts, donuts, cider, & now Relic on each return visit, so I am glad they keep updating their logo products. Just keep the address Webster, NY on each gift product, so I keep purchasing the items as gifts & as souvenirs. 🤑 Another great thing is they now have free nice plain gift bags with twine handles and pretty stuffing paper. It makes giving their items as gifts VERY easy. 12/31/19: Fun shopping. Neat new cap, apple cider, & the world's best fried cakes. You can buy a single serving of their superior fresh apple cider for if you just want a container the same size as a single serving soda pop bottle. Lovely cute gifts galore. You can absolutely find a fun unique gift for any friend or family member here. Pretty seasonal displays for your own home & as gifts. Bird food for birds staying here for the winter. 6/6/21: It was nice to visit this quaint welcoming Webster treasure. April 15th, 2023: I love ❤️ shopping 🛍 at this great Webster, NY country store! 2/29/24: The merchandise buyer lady was lovely,...

I've been coming to this place for over 45 years. My father would get cider and donuts for a family treat on Sunday mornings. In sixth grade I would ride my no-speed bicycle 10 miles just to get here, because it was worth it. This is a family-owned business that is so unique it's a little hard to describe. They have homemade baked goods and preserves. They have old-fashioned candies. They have Fried Cake that's one of the best things I ever put in my mouth, including bacon. I always get the glazed fried cakes! They carry country-ware and antique-style home furnishings and knick knacks, many handmade. Added to that are rabbits you could pet, a glass-walled hive of bees making honey in the wax comb, a free apple bin for kids, local maple syrups, FRESH-pressed apple cider (the tap on the barn wall comes in from the press room), and a wide open rustic space smelling of fruit and sweet spices year-round. The variety of apples sold, as displayed in the bushels used to pick them from the on-premesis orchards, numbers in the dozens. They offer hot and cold drinks as well as hard cider. I like to enjoy mulled cider and horehound sweet treats in one of their porch rocking chairs, swaying back and forth next to the firewood-filled apple crates, inhaling the blossom-scented breeze while watching the orange sunset. I do not know the proprietors and have no relationship to this business except as a customer; I just love this place for the special unique Great Lakes Plain farm store it is and sincerely hope it never goes away. If you're from out of town, and especially from out of state, this is a visit to true upstate New York and one...

A weekend afternoon at Schutt's Apple Mill is the perfect blend of rustic charm and delicious indulgence. From the moment you step onto the property, the scent of fresh apples and warm cider donuts fills the air, setting the stage for a cozy and memorable experience.

The mill itself is packed with character—wooden shelves stocked with locally made jams, honey, and, of course, the freshest apples you can find. Whether you're there for a casual stroll through the store or an adventurous apple-picking excursion, Schutt's delivers on its promise of a quintessential autumn afternoon (though it's a delight year-round).

The highlight? The famous cider donuts, served warm and dusted with cinnamon sugar. Paired with a cold or hot cup of fresh apple cider, it’s the kind of simple pleasure that makes you want to savor every bite. And if you're lucky enough to visit during peak apple season, the pick-your-own experience adds an extra layer of fun to the visit.

Beyond the food, Schutt's has a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere, with a staff that’s knowledgeable and eager to share insights on different apple varieties. It’s the kind of place that invites you to slow down, enjoy the moment, and soak in the best of upstate New York’s agricultural heritage.

Whether you're visiting with family, friends, or just looking for a peaceful afternoon to yourself, Schutt's Apple Mill is a local gem worth returning to time...