The Milk Pail — Local services in Town of Southampton

Please do not bring children to The Milk Pail, unless they are 18 or over. I visited The Milk Pail for the first time this morning. The store was empty with the exception of the clerk behind the counter and a woman making donuts. The woman making donuts did not greet me, but made sure to tell me the stores policy does not allow children in the store. There was no one in the store and my masked daughter was going to hold my hand the entire time. The donut woman continued to reiterate that it is the stores policy to not allow children in the store. When I asked her why, she kept repeating the story policy. The store clerk was watching the entire time, she saw my disappointment and my daughter’s sadness. She walked us outside and we had a pleasant discussion. 5 stars to the store clerk, 1 star for Milk Pail’s Rigid rules and the unpleasant...

We passed by the milk Pail on our way home from sag harbor .. I remembered I saw it on ch12 news.. so I turned around to see what they had to offer. What a lovely place to visit ! We met Amy , the owner . she was so warm , friendly and full of knowledge. I learned so much about apples . Types, tartness, sweetness , growing patterns and more . All the cakes , pies and cookies were delicious. I am so happy we turned around and went back to shop there. It’s not just a store it’s...

Really amazing cider donuts and apple dumplings. They also have local soaps and candles available which were pretty awesome. The croissants were very stale but the manager had no problem issuing a refund. Im not sure she took my word for it, but she otherwise handled it appropriately. Im do not know what the average experience was prior to covid but they had strict policies in place when I went in October. You cannot pick up anything you do not intend...