Florida | St. Augustine | 8 Recommended Restaurants

With countless dining options in St. Augustine, it can be hard to choose! Here’s a curated list to help you decide 🍽️. I’ve personally only tried Columbia Restaurant (check my previous post if you’re curious!), but the others come highly recommended by a friendly gentleman who works at the visitor information center — his suggestions were too good not to share! All restaurants are located near historic St. George Street 🏛️, so you can easily explore based on your mood and cravings. 1️⃣ Columbia Restaurant Google 4.4⭐ (8.1k reviews) $$ The oldest Spanish restaurant in the U.S. Beautiful setting, great ambiance, and delicious food 🇪🇸. 2️⃣ Harry's Seafood, Bar & Grille Google 4.6⭐ (10k reviews) $$ A Florida chain serving Southern-style seafood dishes 🦞. 3️⃣ Burger Buckets Google 4.3⭐ (2.9k reviews) $$ Specializes in burgers, breakfast, milkshakes, and homemade desserts 🍔🍳. 4️⃣ Pizza Time Google 4.3⭐ (4.5k reviews) $$ Offers over 20 pizza varieties. Once voted “2nd Best Pizza in the U.S.” 🍕. 5️⃣ Prohibition Kitchen Google 4.5⭐ (4.8k reviews) $$ A bar offering burgers, sandwiches, and cocktails with live music performances 🎸🍹. 6️⃣ Meehan's Irish Pub & Seafood House Google 4.4⭐ (3.2k reviews) $$ An Irish pub with American burgers, traditional Irish food, and seafood. Overlooks the river — great views! 🍀🌊 7️⃣ O C White's Seafood & Spirits Google 4.2⭐ (3k reviews) $$ Seafood restaurant also serving brunch 🦐🥂. 8️⃣ A1A Ale Works Restaurant & Taproom Google 4.2⭐ (2.4k reviews) $$ Features American sandwiches and steaks. Offers fresh draft beer, wine, and cocktails 🥩🍻. #Florida #FloridaTravel #StAugustine #RestaurantRecommendations #USATravel #FoodGuide #HistoricTown