Indianapolis Must-Eat | St. Elmo Steak House – A Century-Old Legend!

Opened in 1902, this iconic steakhouse is a timeless classic – winner of the prestigious James Beard America’s Classics Award 🏆. Located in downtown Indy, the interior remains unchanged, transporting you back in time with its historic charm. 📌 TL;DR: A must-visit for tradition, but manage expectations – it’s about heritage, not innovation. 📍 Reservations essential for weekend dinners! 🎯 Must-orders: Shrimp Cocktail, Lobster Bisque, Dry-Aged Steak! 🍤 Shrimp Cocktail (since 1902!) Jumbo shrimp + ultra-fiery horseradish sauce 🌶️😭 So spicy it’ll make you cry, but it’s legendary! 🦞 Lobster Bisque (hidden gem!) Rich, creamy, packed with lobster chunks – pure comfort! 🥩 Dry-Aged USDA Prime Tomahawk Ribeye (2 lbs!) Charred outside, juicy inside – simple seasoning lets the meat shine. Note: Leaner cut, slightly drier than top-tier steakhouses like Peter Luger. 🥔 Mashed Potatoes (with skins & chunks) Classic, hearty, and nostalgic! 🍹 Elmo Cola Cocktail Vanilla bourbon + mini Coke bottle + boozy cherry – classy and fun! ⭐ Rating: 4/5 (for history and experience) 💰 Price: ~$100+ per person (before tax/tip) 📅 Visited: May 2025 #Indiana #Indianapolis #SteakLovers #HistoricEats #JamesBeardAward #PurdueLife #IUB #FoodieReview #IndyEats 🥩✨🍷