Must-visit for Indie: St.Elmo – A century-old classic steakhouse guide

Indianapolis’ Timeless Steakhouse: St. Elmo – A Century of Classic American Flavors 🥩🏆 Founded in 1902 and still in its original Downtown Indy location, this iconic steakhouse is a James Beard America’s Classics winner. Its preserved vintage decor feels like stepping into a time machine—thick, rustic, and steeped in history ✨ Why It’s a Must-Visit Century-Old Legacy: Operating for over 120 years, it’s a piece of culinary history with unchanged classic recipes. Authentic Vintage Vibe: The original interior takes you back a century, adding nostalgia to the dining experience. Acclaimed Recognition: Ranked top 38 on Eater Indianapolis’ Must-Eat list and a James Beard awardee—proof of its enduring quality. 🍴 Standout Dishes & Drinks Shrimp Cocktail (Classic Since 1902): A menu staple with plump, sweet, and firm shrimp. The ultra-potent horseradish packs a fiery punch—so spicy it may bring tears, but it’s the signature experience you can’t miss. Go easy on the cocktail sauce if you can’t handle heat! Lobster Bisque (Off-Menu Gem): Upgraded from the standard steak side soup. Rich, creamy, and loaded with large shrimp chunks—comforting and satisfying. Dry-Aged USDA Prime Tom-a-Hawk Ribeye: A showstopping 2-pound bone-in steak. Crispy on the outside, tender inside, with simple seasoning to highlight the natural flavor. It’s leaner (somewhat tough) compared to Peter Luger’s, but the joy of big bites is unbeatable. Mashed Potato: Classic style with potato skins and chunks—hearty and pairs perfectly with steak. Elmo Cola (Signature Cocktail): Elegant blend of vanilla bourbon, a small bottle of cola, and a maraschino cherry—sophisticated and flavorful. 📌 Practical Info 🏠 Name: St. Elmo Steak House📍 Address: Downtown Indianapolis, IN Reservation Tip: Book ahead for weekend dinners—this popular spot fills up fast. Expectation Check: It’s a classic worth (visiting), but don’t anticipate modern twists—enjoy it for its traditional, timeless flavors. Recommended Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ #Indiana #Indianapolis #IndianapolisFood #Steakhouse #ClassicDining #PurdueUniversity #IndianaUniversityBloomington #StudentEats #JamesBeardAward