This 86-Year-Old Brooklyn Institution Was Just Crowned Home Of “The Best Pizza Slice” In New York State

As the grand pizza chase goes on to find the very best in all of New York City—one Brooklyn pizza spot has earned a recent nod as the best pizza slice in all of New York State . From a humble pushcart to an iconic Brooklyn landmark, L&B Spumoni Gardens has been perfecting pizza for over 80 years now, and according to the Food Network’s new list, they have the most delectable slice in the entire state. The story begins with Ludovico Barbati, who arrived in Brooklyn from Italy in 1917. He started selling pizza and spumoni from a horse-drawn cart in Gravesend and Bensonhurst, quickly winning over the neighborhood with his crispy, cheesy creations. By 1939, he had established a permanent home on 86th Street—a space that remains the heart of L&B Spumoni Gardens today . L&B is famous for its square Sicilian slices —thick, airy crusts topped with tangy tomato sauce and gooey cheese. As the Food Network notes, > “This slice sets itself apart with an upside-down composition. The cheese is sprinkled right on top of the dough, which is then layered with a sweet tomato sauce and finished with a flurry of salty Parmesan flakes on top. When it’s pulled out the oven, the thick crust is lightly browned around the edges with a springy center.” And while the pizza gets all the glory, L&B also serves classic Italian dishes and their signature spumoni , a sweet treat that helped make the pizzeria a neighborhood staple. The family’s dedication to flavor and tradition means every dish has a story—and a loyal following. 📍 L&B Spumoni Gardens — 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 🍕 More info and full menu Source: https://secretnyc.co/best-pizza-slice-in-new-york-state-2025-food-network/