L&B Spumoni Gardens — Restaurant in New York

I love this place. Came here for dinner to celebrate my daughters graduation. Highly recommend reservations if you are planning to dine inside the restaurant part. This place gets really packed inside or out. There is a small parking garage for L&B customers only.

This place is known for their Sicilian square pizza. We dined inside. We decided not to eat pizza for tonight. Instead, we ordered appetizers and entrees. For appetizer, we ordered fried shrimp and mozzarella sticks. Fried shrimp are big and delicious. Super tasty with a squeeze of lemon on it, and the tartar sauce they serve it with is delicious. Mozzarella sticks were nice and cheesy. You definitely get that cheese pull effect.

For entrees, we ordered chicken parmigiana, penne with vodka sauce with grilled chicken, chicken Caesar salad, calamari with linguini red sauce, penne with grilled chicken in pesto sauce, burger basket with French fries. Chicken Caesar salad was delicious. The romaine lettuce was nice and crisp, and the grilled chicken was seasoned and cooked very well. The penne in vodka sauce was nice and creamy, mushrooms are added, and peas. Penne with grilled chicken in pesto sauce was one of my favorites. The pesto sauce was delicious. The calamari in red sauce was really good, and it had tons of calamari. Chicken parmigiana was super tender and cheesy. The burger basket was good. Everything we had was packing with flavors, and the portion sizes are huge. Easily, three people can eat from one pasta dish.

For dessert, everyone wanted ice cream. We ordered chocolate, cookies & cream, creamscicle, and strawberry ice-cream flavors. My favorite is the creamscicle, but all are rich in flavor.

I highly recommend you try this place. There's is something on the menu for everyone. Staff is super friendly and attentive. Service is quick. The food...

If you’re a food lover, L&B Spumoni Gardens is a culinary treasure that you simply must experience. From the moment you arrive, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough and authentic Italian spices sets the tone for what will undoubtedly be a memorable meal.

Let’s talk about the pizza – the Sicilian slice is an absolute masterpiece. The crust is the perfect balance of crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. The rich, tangy tomato sauce is generously spread on top, layered with just the right amount of creamy, melted mozzarella. It’s not your typical slice, but that’s exactly what makes it so special. Each bite is packed with flavor, and the unique topping order gives it an unforgettable texture and taste.

The spumoni is a true standout – creamy, flavorful, and an ideal way to end your meal. Whether you choose classic chocolate, pistachio, or another variety, you’re in for a treat. It’s not overly sweet, and the flavors are beautifully balanced.

The staff deserves a shout-out for their friendly, attentive service. Even on busy days, they handle the crowd with efficiency and professionalism, ensuring every guest feels valued.

The outdoor seating area is another highlight. It’s perfect for enjoying your food while soaking in the vibrant energy of the place. Whether you’re with family, friends, or dining solo, it’s a fantastic spot to relax and savor the experience.

L&B Spumoni Gardens is more than just a pizzeria – it’s a destination. The quality of the food, the welcoming atmosphere, and the rich history behind the establishment make it a must-visit. If you’re in Brooklyn, do yourself a favor and stop by. This is the kind of place you’ll keep coming back to, time and time again.

Feel free to personalize this further with any specific details...

A large group of friends & fam (~15ppl) has had tradition of annual dinner at Spumoni Gardens. We all look forward to it, and for this year went last night (7/5/24). We had a long table in the "annex" room off to the side.

While the shared food was great as always (fried zucchini and calamari apps, caesar and pear salads, 2 unbeatable Sicilian square pies, rigatoni with meatballs and also with vodka sauce, veal parm... and 2 spumoni dessert platters), the poor service put a damper on our meal experience.

Our waiter was unhelpful, not friendly, often AWOL, and we had to ask him for basic things multiple times. Platters of food all arrived without serving utensils... water pitchers weren't refilled... pastas arrived with no cheese for sprinkling... and some dishes we ordered (e.g. chicken francese) never arrived.

We realize you don't go to this crazy-bustling place for the service, but in all the years we've being going, we've never had a bad experience. On the contrary, the waiters have always hustled, helped with ordering, and taken very good care of us, despite the crowds and pace of the place. This made last night's poor service stand out even more.

As we were leaving, we gave feedback to the manager, who apologized and comped us 2 quarts of spumoni to go, which we appreciated.

We'll probably be back again next year, but if we encounter service anything like last night's, rather than hoping it will improve during the meal, we'll let the manager know right away so they can address it. Shame that a cherished tradition was marred last night by such indifferent, unhelpful service (for which an 18% gratuity was included in the check for parties...