Nickolini's Pizza — Restaurant in Area H (Lighthouse Country)

My kids were pressing hard for one of the chain pizza joints, but I wanted to support a local business. I knew we would probably spend more money than at a franchise place, so I was prepared for that. But $10 for a small cheese? We had 3 pizzas, all different kinds. We all felt they were just okay, nothing great, something I might make at home. The crust was dry and tasteless, and could have used some olive oil and salt or parmesan cheese. There was more sauce than I like, and there were onions! on the ham and pineapple pizza. Don't remember reading that on the menu. I am glad to have supported a small business, but did not really enjoy the...

Called to place an order at 5:45 was asked rudely to wait on hold. 10 minutes later still hadn't come back but I could hear them laughing and chatting. I finally hung up. It's now 6:35 and I have been calling them insistently trying to get a hold of them. They still hadn't noticed that I was on hold, or in this case no longer on hold. At this point I just wanted to express my disappointment. I've always recommended this place but I won't anymore! I knew the service has always been really bad but this is just...

Keep driving go to ship and shore deep bay well worth the money .Wife loved her pizza my son and i had pizzas over done on top but not cooked inside the dough was still RAW! It was too late to take back so i didnt bother. First time was alright but ill never go back after this. Besides that they are unpredictable for open times, drove past wanting o try the pizza out many times to have them closed 20 minutes before close time or not open at all when according to their schedule its supposed to be open. very...