Fenwick Pie Co. — Restaurant in Pelham

Our first time visiting your store today. 1000% delicious. My daughter and I both had the Southwestern wrap combo. Super duper value for money and "fantastically delicious"....if that is a saying LOL. Very hearty and tasty. We shared The Long John eclair, fantastic. After our tulip farm visit, we came back to buy some pies home. Your blueberry pie is one of the best I've ever tasted, not too sweet, awesome crumble, even more awesome shortcrust, not to mention that blueberry filling. (I work in the food industry so have discerning taste 😉😉) We are baking 2 small pies and the Taco Cheeseburger macaroni now for a late dinner for the rest of the fam. 😋 Also bought 6 mini tarts for dessert. 😉😁 If it was a cooler day, we would have tried the soup too. Well done! What a hidden gem. As well, staff members were super nice. It would be even more perfect if we can have a couple more picnic tables for...

The most delicious pot pies and quiches you will ever have. Don’t be surprised when you pull up there is a line as they are well worth the wait. Owner is very friendly and accommodating. I called once to ask if they had any breakfast quiches available. There were none available at the time but she would call me when they did make more. 2 weeks later I received a phone call that quiches were available. I was amazed and pleasantly surprised my request was not lost in the shuffle. Do yourself a favour and get some pot pies or quiches from the Fenwick Pie Company. You will want to keep...

Today I visited The Fenwick Pie Company for the first time. Oh my goodness, am I ever glad that I chose to. I brought home three Butter Chicken pies and the one that I had was absolutely fantastic. The chicken and vegetables were so tender and along with just the right amount of Indian spices, as I was eating it, I was making sounds that I usually only make in bed. Also the pie crust was the most flavourful and flakiest that I have ever had. Thank you for a great meal. I will...