Craig’s Cookies — Restaurant in St. John's

These cookies are spectacular! I’m literally still eating it and had to write the review. 3 of us went in on a whim and we each got 2 different kinds (one of us got 4 different kinds) All of them were hands down 11/10! The cookies were all so fresh, soft and delicious. Also the store smelled fantastic! The cookies tasted like Craig took your favourite childhood memory then carefully and lovingly baked that magic right in, each one special just for you. You take a bite and you’re instantly 11, holding your puppy for the first time, heart so filled you can’t speak. Pretty sure Craig is a Wizard and I’m here for it. Craig’s Cookies is open from 10am till 10pm-every day! Crazy. There was a line at 7:30pm. We’re staying at the Sheraton, it’s worth staying here just to be close to the cookies. I’ll put that in their review as well - book for the view, stay for Craig’s Cookies. I’m currently enjoying a Mars one, it’s the best cookie I’ve ever tasted. Go get a cookies, you’ll never be the same, in the best...

Delicious & Nostalgic.

I received my Cookies and Cream flavored cookie at a warm temperature. From my understanding all of the cookies are kept warm to be served. The warmth, flavor and texture of the cookie reminded me of an inexpensive homemade cookie (with some extra yummy ingredients added) which was delightful but also why it left me wondering why I paid $3 for 1 cookie--Of course I then remembered that a lot goes into a business and I enjoy not having to bake so I was fine with paying that much, as well if I'd tried more than 1 cookie I think I may have been pleased by the fact that each cookie is perfectly made with just the right amount of softness and crunch.

The bakery was spacious, bright, and appeared clean.

Service was as warm as the cookies.

No coffee available at St. John's location yet but server mentioned they were working on it. Milk is offered.

A fair variety of flavors to choose from.

I did not notice any...

My order on 06-28-2024 was perfect. All of the cookies were fresh, and nice. They put in all chocolate chips and even the sour gummy candies I asked for. And the worker that day gave me sprinkles and I loved them.

Older review: 5 star rating I love these cookies. They should call their Oreo cookie inception, because it’s a cookie inside a cookie, inside a Craig’s cookie. Love..Love..Love

Another old review: 5 star rating I am a happy customer again. I ordered a box of surprise me. I mentioned that I liked chocolate, licorice, and gummy flavor and they hooked me up. I even received a sour gummy candy cookie which was cool. I did happen to see a dark cookie and I thought cool double chocolate, but I was wrong. It turned out to be a very spicy ginger bread cookie. I told them I was up for whatever, I’m eating my words. Be warned just because something looks like double chocolate doesn't mean...