This past Sunday, 8 August 2021, my wife, daughter and I ate at Orlando’s Restaurant. We were vacationing in St. Lucia, and staying at local resort. It rained all morning. In the early afternoon, when the sun finally peaked, we quickly made our way to town on foot, looking for a place to have lunch. We first passed Orlando’s. It was unassuming, without the bling-bling lights or signage intended to attract tourists. We kept walking. Everything in town was closed. We slowly resigned to eat at the Resort. On our way back, and approaching Orlando’s, we heard a group of dinners eating, talking, and having what seemed to be a good time. We tried to go in. The door was locked. We knocked on the door. A young woman greeted us and told that the restaurant was in fact closed, and was hosting a private party. She told to wait for one minute while she checked to see if they could accommodate us. She returned and asked us to wait at the bar, while she prepared our table.
While we waited at the bar, we struck a casual conversation through the “window” separating the bar and the kitchen, with a man who we initially thought was the cook. This is not surprising for the man was cooking! I don’t remember the conversation. It must have been of the “where are you guys from” variety.
Looking back now, I wished I had taken pictures of the front, entrance, and bar area of the restaurant. A meal to us is never merely about the food: It is about the company sharing the meal; the atmosphere; the staff; physical environment; etc.
I am now back in NY, and trying to recall the interior of the restaurant. It was a hot day. We were walking all throughout the town. We were sweating. Once we were seated, we were given cold towels, which we placed around our necks and foreheads. That was refreshing.
We were made to feel very welcomed at Orlando’s. We eat out quite a bit over the past four decades and and I can think of being made to feel so welcomed only twice: once by Chef Marcus Samuelsson’s Aquavit, the high end Scandinavian restaurant, when he seated my party in the middle of the restaurant and brought our dishes personally, waited for us to taste his offerings, and, as I remember, recommended and offered a tasting aquavit drink menu. The other was at a client’s Thai Restaurant near Lincoln Center where we ate before attending a performance at the Metropolitan Opera House.
We had the chicken and fish prix fixe dishes. They were prepared with local ingredients, with flair and professional precision. Our daughter who is a “Food Network” fan said upon seeing and tasting her meal: “You know the Chef is clearly professionally trained”. We had no idea what we had walked into; or who Chef Orlando was.
Our first course consisted of soup. The main course, along with our meat choices, consisted of rice and peas, mac and cheese, and something else that now escapes me. Our last course was dessert, compromising of a freshly made coconut cake with freshly made ice cream.
Chef Orlando juxtaposes flavors and textures in ways that are both complex and finely tuned. More significantly, his ideas don’t seem to be merely parroting Caribbean traditions. He adds and subtracts just the right amounts to be true and respectful to the Caribbean tradition, while ensuring that it remains a living thing.
Chef Orlando took some time to discuss with us the current state of affairs in NY State. This was right before our then Governor, Andrew Cuomo, embroiled in a scandal involving harassing 11 women under his employed, was forced to resign. We learned a little about his background.
Later, after leaving, we learned about his impressive background. But that Sunday early afternoon, we were strangers, looking for food and water, and he opened his door...
Read moreMarch2023: party of 2.5 Big summary: Fish was delicious that it melted in your mouth and one of the dessert plates was good but the rest needs some more work for the high prices. Mind you, many people come here but the majority is for tourists and are mostly white presenting. If you are on a budget I would recommend local food that local people eat at. Overall place is 3/5 mostly because of the fish. For some more details read below:
Jamaica drink in shot glass very sweet tasted like Kool-aid distracting from its natural properties of the bitter and sour hibiscus plant, I was not a fan of this and also there was very little of it to try. The non-native cane sugar was a nice addition but also added to the sweetness aspect. 0/5
Cocktail dish in a shot glass was next on the menu and similar tastings to a mexican cocktail dish which was nice to taste again but nothing out of the ordinary just in a small version.1/5
A creamy green soup was well presented and had creamy sweet hues very savory and the texture of toasted bread with lots of butter and cream complemented the soup very well. 4/5
I do not consume pork so this was the review of my food mate: Next Pork serving in a small cup the flavoring was not bad but to her it tasted like chicken jello or meat jello which reminded her of cat food in a can. Like she said the tasting was good but the texture was not it. 3/5 I had the salad in a margarita cup and it was simple and nice but not what I would expect for the price. 2/5
Food in sauce pan had traditional Caribbean spices and sazon it was well cooked, but again nothing out of the ordinary that we had on the island. 4.5/5
No picture of the fish but this fish is to die for was very well prepared presented and would order that next time if I would come here. 5/5
Dessert in a square small plate was nice and hot reminded you of a hot brownie with creamy flavorings 4.5/5
If you do not like coconut I dont recommend the slice of pie. I personally liked the texture and the low sweetness. But the texture was too crunchy and got stuck in my teeth 3/5.
The server and hosts were very forgetful and didn't communicate with the chef that I only ate sea food, I even spoke to the chef and told him that but its a hustle and I get it no biggie. Other than that the experience was nice we ate outside and...
Read moreAfter reading much about Chef Orlando Satchell’s accomplishments, awards, and creativity, my wife and I were extremely excited to be visiting St. Lucia on a cruise at the end of February. I contacted Orlando’s by email 7 weeks prior to confirm our lunch reservation celebrating a significant birthday. One-week prior to the reservation date, I confirmed the reservation by email as well as doing so by WhatsApp the morning of the reservation, as I had heard during our cruise that Chef Orlando had cancelled a separate ‘Taste of St. Lucia’ excursion planned for that morning, due to his illness. In both instances, it was confirmed that my reservation was still good. On arriving at the restaurant at the scheduled time, we found it closed. After looking around and knocking on the door, a woman answered who was cleaning the floors and she wanted to know what we wanted, and we explained. She called a man who also wanted to know what we wanted so we explained the reservation and the multiple confirmations, and he seemed surprised. He also said Chef Orlando was not sick, and he did not know where that rumor came from. He said that Chef Orlando was elsewhere on the Island buying ingredients. He guided us to another woman who took us upstairs to a table and offered us a bottle of water. We were the only diners there. I inquired about some wine, and she did not seem to know what Orlando’s had and if the White wines were even chilled, so she went to check. We selected what she offered verbally, and she went to chill the bottle. On her return and I asked if they had a menu and she said, “you only have to make one choice, chicken or fish” and “how you want it cooked - fully or half.” There was no explanation of any other appetizers, courses, side dishes, etc. available for lunch. Clearly, they were not ready for us despite the reservation and follow-up confirmations. We figured this whole welcome was just too weird and paid for the water and left. This experience was a huge disappointment to us as we had travelled over 3,500 miles to sample...
Read more