Learn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
I’ve had food from The Little York twice recently. The first time I had a smash burger and sat by myself at the bar. The burger was awesome and the servers were very friendly, so I was excited to try another meal. This time I picked up a chicken parm and fries to-go. I’m sure the to-go element of the dinner caused some of the problem, but the food was not kept warm at all and the sandwich really creeped me out. It was a gigantic, barely breaded piece of rubbery chicken. In my opinion, chicken parm should be made with thinly pounded, tender cutlets that are battered, fried and very crispy. This was the opposite of that.
Anyway, the burger was so good that I’ll go back for that, but I would never get the chicken parm or any other chicken dish.
On a separate note, the restaurant does not share their WiFi password with patrons and there’s virtually no cell reception. In 2023 you cannot have a bar in an area with barely any phone service, like Little York, and not have WiFi available to customers. Not a particularly welcoming or safe policy.
Update 3 Months Later: Downgrading my review to 1 star. Ordered a large pie half plain, half pepperoni, well-done. Was awful. Bland, greasy and very expensive. I asked for a well-done pie and it tasted as though it was nearly raw dough that was cooked in a microwave. All of the cheese was separating under pools of grease, the sauce had no flavor at all and the whole thing was essentially uncooked. I will not be going back to the...
Read more
What an experience! This restaurant was JAM packed with such fantastic staff! My best friend and I came in to this restaurant for some drinks on a Friday night and they did NOT disappoint! We were able to get seats at the bar pretty quickly and had a view of the team doing the most! The love that poured out of the kitchen was evident. The staff was all smiles and it felt welcoming consistently through our experience. We took a moment to try a couple of their deserts as well. Their ice cream sandwiches are next level… they make it all from scratch and you can TASTE the love they put into everything they make! The cookie was crisp at the edges but chewy in the middle. It was the perfect consistency to enjoy with a generous dollop of vanilla ice cream! They also had an impressive (or should i say espresso-sive) espresso cake. The plate was garnished a way you wouldn’t expect from a small town spot! They really raise the bar here with expectations! Looking around, you could tell everyone felt right at home. Restaurant was beautifully lit and the noise level was assuring that everyone was having a blast. I’m thankful for my experience here and you BET my best friend and i will be back! (Seriously don’t sleep on their deserts! There’s...
Read more
The owners of this adorable old town restaurant have done a beautiful job with their renovations. The decor is beautiful and elegant. When you go you need to plan to go early as they do not take reservations (personally I wish they did), and the restaurant is at full capacity within an hour after opening.
I have been going to the Little York for years when it was The Little York Tavern and now with it being The Little York. The new owners have blown the previous restaurant out of the water. The only thing that is the same is the wonderful delicious pizza.
They believe in fresh local food from farm to table. The steaks and hamburgers are not only fabulous, but so reasonably priced.
I recently had the short ribs that came with real homemade mashed potatoes that were creamy and delicious. The rib meat just fell off the bone and was so tender and flavorful and a beautiful presentation.
The menu and specials are always something a little different that is totally well worth price.
I almost hate giving this review because this has now become one of our favorite places to go and kind of want to keep this jem to myself.
All kidding aside, they are truly a beautiful and delicious addition to the tiny little hamlet of...
Read more
