Olde Time New England Seafood Company — Restaurant in Athol

This has to be one of the BEST seafood restaurants my family and I have had. They have GREAT food, service is amazing super friendly, the quantity of food you get is incredible, great prices for the food you get and overall an amazing experience! In the photo I shared we had ordered haddock, fried calamari and clam strips... usually restaurants never give a good amount of seafood and you barely get any, this place outdid themselves. I would rate this place higher than 5 stars if I could! Thank you guys 😊

EDIT WE JUST ORDERED SHRIMP SCAMPI AND IT WAS THE MOST DELICIOUS FOOD IVE EVER TASTED. NO JOKE IT WAS FOOD ORGASM. THIS WILL BE OUR NEW FAVORITE DISH AND WILL BE ORDERING FROM THEM EVERYTIME. THEY NEVER EVER DISAPPOINT. IF YOU ARE CURIOUS TO ORDER FROM THEM, JUST DO IT!!! I WOULD RATE 10 STARS IF I COULD. BEST FOOD AROUND HERE. BEST CLAM CHOWDER. 👌 ON TOP OF THAT THIS WAS ONLY $38 FOR 2 PLATES WITH GARLIC...

Everything was fabulous! I love having a great seafood restaurant a mile down the road from home. I only have a photo of mine to share, but my family said their meals were delicious too. Ok, I'm revising my review from several months ago. Everything was wonderful then, but tonight, it was hardly edible. I got cole slaw instead of carrots. It used to be delicious. It wasn't even chopped enough to eat. The rice pilaf tasted like it was old and reheated and it was still cold. As for the baked haddock, yuk is all I can say. It was cold and tasted horrible. My cats wouldn't even eat it. So, obviously you have a new cook that isn't very good. I tried to call and speak personally to you, but all I got was a busy signal for 3 mins. Anyway, I'm sorry, but I won't be back. So much for the same food as fabulous Pete and Henry's was. Surely thought I'd found them again for a...

Would have loved to actually try the food here but when I called at 6:30 on a SATURDAY NIGHT the woman told me, ""We're not talking anymore orders tonight, we're busy".......um, yeah, I thought that was the entire point of operating a restaurant, you know, to get busy, sell food, turn tables, make money!!?? Maybe they don't make enough in tips with take-out orders so they dodge them, idk. We would eat in but this place closes really early (8:30)and my husband and I do paving so coming in to eat on the way home isn't really an option (I wouldn't want to sit next to us and eat lol). I just couldn't believe that they were refusing to take orders 2 hours before closing, I mean, if you're busy that's OK, we were willing to wait the hour for food in Athol that...