Dominick's Pizzeria & Restaurant — Restaurant in Blairstown

Haven't been to this location in years. I decided to try every pizza in town. I work at a pizza place on the side so I know pizza places make pies in advance for rushes. I asked that my pies be made on the spot from scratch, the girl didn't get it. I just went to ordering the Stromboli, The Cheese Pie and a Buffalo Chicken. When I went to pick it up, the owner looked like he was in a bad mood or just didn't like the customers, or didn't like what I asked on the phone, which was a legit request. Anyway, I was admiring that my softball photos were still on the wall. It was nice to see in my old hometown but when I mentioned it to the owner, he did not care, smile or engage. It was kinda awkward. The pizza was good, the stromboli was not good but I won't go back. Their pizza prices are also more expensive...

Pizza was nowhere near fresh. Crust was chewy and the cheese was way firm. Almost like when you microwave a slice ( never do that ) I only took it home, which is about 5 miles and it was not hot and tasted like it was reheated. The box didn’t even get warm. When you get a fresh pie, you have to switch hands right? Yeah, not here. Went on a Saturday night and 5:15 and the place was empty and dark. I will not be going back. Oh, and the place uses one of those heating racks, like Pizza Hut and Poppa John’s. Real pizza comes out of a Pizza Oven. Not that glorified space heater. Check the pictures. What is that black line about the cheese and below the crust????? Oh it’s...

Hey, this place is great. Taking a ride to the Delaware Water Gap to see the colors, my wife and I stopped in Blairstown to grab an early dinner. Not finding a lot of restaurants we fortunately pass this pizzeria. Ordered a Italian sub and salad we were very pleased with the sub and the bread OMG. Great service along with great Halloween decorations made this visit wonderful. Will return next time...