Old Mill Creamery, LLC — Restaurant in Buffalo Township

I enjoyed it. They've taken the crumbling ruin (1782 roughly) of an old grist mill in Cowan on 192 and rebuilt it into a modern facility. I remember as a kid avoiding the place because it wasn't safe to be near.

Ice cream ? Hand packed waffle cones are the usual seller but you can get it in a cup, too.

They've got a lot of the usual selections, along with flavors like blueberry, orange dreamscicle, and teaberry.

There's also coffee, milk, other dairy products and I even saw Angus burgers and steaks in a cold display case.

Seating inside is somewhat limited, but on nice clear days there are plenty of outdoor seats to choose from. From right outside the door, to the picnic tables at the side or even the stream side seating by the bridge, you can find a spot you'll like, while the kids can go play in the small play area.

The owners and staff have done a great job bringing this to...

Old Mill Creamery sets the gold standard for what an ice cream experience should be. Each visit proves their consistency in quality, with classic flavors executed flawlessly and inventive seasonal varieties that keep things exciting. The staff is warm and welcoming, and the space itself is spotless—an inviting environment for families and solo visitors alike.

The homemade waffle cones deserve special mention. I’ve never been a waffle cone enthusiast, yet Old Mill Creamery has changed my mind entirely. The aroma of freshly pressed cones fills the shop, and the taste is every bit as captivating as the scent—crispy, buttery, and the perfect complement to their rich ice creams.

Old Mill Creamery doesn’t just serve ice cream; it delivers an experience that redefines what we expect from a creamery. This is the benchmark against which all others should...

This is a really innovative small business that is 100% worth supporting. They offer a variety of hand dipped (scooped) ice cream flavors that are the best in the area. It's definitely worth getting in their homemade waffle cones.

They also have coffee/lattes and various snacks and other items for sale from other small businesses (potato chips, maple syrup, etc).

This Mennonite-owned business has completed renovated the decaying Cowan mill into a wonderful location. There is drive through service as well. The building looks great and you can enjoy your ice cream on chairs or benches right next to rapid run! They have really done a fantastic job restoring the old mill building, that was on the verge of needing tore down, into a cute modern shop. The staff is always very friendly.

They accept...