Mike's Pizzeria and Tavern — Restaurant in Caledonia Charter Township

Looking for a hidden gem worth the drive? Mike's Pizzeria in Alto, MI is it. From the service to the atmosphere to the food, this spot delivers more than you could ever hope for.

Tucked away in rural Western Michigan, Mike’s Pizzeria greets you with the most delicious collection of smells as soon as you step inside. Right then and there, you’ll feel secure that you’ve made the right decision.

My person and I were greeted so sweetly—and authentically—by Mike himself. Honestly, it was an honor. I first learned of Mike through a hot sub my person brought home after a long day of remote work. What a joy it was to skip making dinner and instead enjoy the hard work and passion of this lovely human. The Italian Sub was perfect (a generous foot-long): flavorful meats and fresh ingredients that blended seamlessly. Capicola, ham, pepperoni, salami, provolone, banana peppers, crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes, Italian dressing, and oregano—every bite felt like a warm hug from home. As a Jersey girl who often misses the abundance of good Italian-American food, I was thrilled to find a piece of home here.

My gorgeous Meat-Lover opted for the Meat Lover Sub. Dinner was quiet—as it often is when the food is that good—and he respectfully and happily polished it off.

When Mike asked for my name, I made sure to thank him for his work. That sub was so good, I couldn’t bring myself to stray from it on my visit to the restaurant—I knew I’d find comfort in the familiar.

The experience didn’t stop there. Another kind staff member noticed my interest in the giant chocolate chip cookies displayed by the register. Speckled with what looked like sea salt, they were already tempting enough, but when I learned the salt was “Scandinavian,” I was completely sold. “Bougie,” he shared, and for those who love the finer things, it was the perfect touch for a massive delight. Naturally, my person followed suit and got one too.

The staff was busy but precious—smiling and confident, as though they knew they weren’t just serving great food but also creating a memorable experience. That mix of care and expertise made this quaint corner of Alto, MI even more special.

Greater Grand Rapids, count yourself lucky! You’ve got an incredible, delicious, and chill spot to invest your hunger and time. If you’re ever near Alto—or even if you’re not—make the trip to Mike’s Pizzeria. You won’t regret...

First time Detroit-style taster here!

We were visiting nearby when we decided to grab some pizza as our late dinner. Mike’s, being around the corner, was our ideal distance.

Our order was a double sauce, no cheese (sorry, we have lactose issues!) supreme pizza. After 20 minutes, we arrived to pickup only to find that our order had swapped instructions, double cheese no sauce! The cashier and pizza maker immediately rectified the situation with their positive hospitality and friendly composure - they went to make a new pizza and offered to deliver it to our vehicle as we waited. Sure enough, 10-15 minutes later and 50% off our initial cost, we got the pizza.

The first detail we noticed was how beautifully prepared it was - the ingredients were blended and balanced where each bite felt exactly like the last. The second detail was the base of the crust being slightly undercooked to the point where the crust looked and felt like mozzarella. The latter is likely a result of feeling the need to rush our order since it had to be remade. However, the rest of the crust was perfect.

This is a safe five star corner pizzeria that is sure to satisfy the whole party - that and the great customer service easily ranks it above the dominos and pizza huts. The undercooked dough is the only reason why I went for four stars, but I believe our order...

My family has been buying from Mike's for years, maybe a decade by now, and the food has always been fantastic. Hot and fresh, good ingredients and quick service.

Tonight we had a bit of a problem, when they forgot a sald and mixed up "cheese steak" and "cheese sticks." Honestly, my dad mumbles so bad, the cheese stick one is totally on my dad and his inability to pronounce words! Haha. But having missing food from an order is never fun, and can cause a lot of discomfort.

Before we had the chance to call, complain and get all upset, Mike called us and apologized. Refunded the missing/mumbled food and gave us a discount for next time.

I dont know how to say this with more effusiveness, no one does this anymore. No one is so on top of their own business that they know, in minutes, that they've made a small mistake. Then to have the class to call and make it right before we had the chance to get all upset; it shows character and class that is desperately lacking in today's world.

My parents love you guys, and would have kept going back no matter what. But now me, my family and any friend that will listen will also be going out of our way to patron your restaurant.

Thank you for being decent in indecent times. You are appreciated. You are loved....