Everly's Ice Cream — Restaurant in Caledonia

The menu is kind of overwhelming, so by the time I ordered I forgot that 1 topping is included. The employee who took my order did not remind me/ask if we wanted any toppings. I remembered after our order was already scooped and I felt weird asking for toppings at that point since the one who took our order wasn't very friendly and neither was the one who scooped it. I specifically wanted to go there for their "playdough" (blue moon + cookie dough) that they just advertised on fb a few days prior, but that wasn't an option and I didn't see any cookie dough to add to the blue moon (also why I forgot we got toppings). The plain blue moon tasted like Cedar Crest, which isn't bad, but I could just go to the store and buy it... The snickerdoodle cookies tasted freezer burned. Overall very...

Super cozy little place. Everything is impossibly good. If you have a sweet tooth you'd be hard pressed to find something on the menu you don't like. I've heard a few complaints about their prices but respectfully I feel like those people are comparing the prices to 10 years ago. With all the ingredients/products being high quality and the fact that they take everything to the next level I feel like the prices are fair. My two favorites are the caramel apple cookies, and cinnamon muffins. If your going to Cliffside park for a game you gotta stop here afterwards. Just remember "Sprinkles are...

I was in there last night with my aunt and cousins. Let me say the owner is SO kind he was baking up some new items for his menu and asked us to be taste testers let me say he exceeded with these new items DELISH!! We had a conversation about adding drinks to his menu he whipped up one of the drinks hes adding in the spring time for me no charge he wanted me to try it first! Speaking for my family we all felt so welcomed and had a great time there! I love everlys and they really do take time to make...