Odyssey's Pizzeria — Restaurant in California

To give some back story of my pizza enjoyment history I want to put my experience into context. I grew up in NJ and am currently living in NY. All my life I have enjoyed great pizza that is well beyond the national average. My standards for pizza enjoyment, I consider to be extremely high.

The pizzas we enjoyed over the span of two days (yes we ordered pizza the next day) was very good and the ingredients were a of a high quality. The crust was fluffy and fresh. The vegetables were delicious.

I would recommend the Peleus Pie or the Montara Mountain. Both have lots of veggies and legitimate meats (not frozen or typical).

The first pie we had at their restaurant and we found that the service was pleasant and quick. The pizzaria takes pride in their food too.

We also had a delivery to our hotel. The estimated time for delivery was bang on and within a few minutes of the estimated time. The driver was friendly and courteous. He even recommended some other options for next time. Unfortunately we were leaving the area shortly and wouldn't be able to take him up on his suggestions. However we would definitely consider ordering take out if they delivered to NY.

Just for some comparison purposes, the pizza sizes are different than what you might expect.

A small is equal to a personal pizza A medium is equal to an adult personal pizza A large is good for 2 hungry adults An Xtra large is good for a family or 1 hungry college student

They are easily the best pizza place I have been to on the...

What a pleasant surprise! My daughter and I stopped in after discovering the Distillery was closed. We walked in at 8:30PM and were welcomed to order, even though it looked like they were closing. We honestly didn’t have high hopes, but we were wrong! Our order: 1. Caesar salad was fresh, dressing tasted homemade (as did the croutons). Chicken was reminiscent of the taqueria from across the street - 10/10. 2. Mozzarella sticks: perfectly done and fresh. Not sure how they pulled that off, but I’m glad they did. Marinara was on point. 10/10. 3. Pizza: 1/2 margarita, 1/2 garden…fresh veggies, sauce was good and they accommodated our request to remove artichoke hearts. Only complaint is that it was slightly underdone (though I think that was because we sat there and waited and they were trying to be as quick as possible) 7/10. We’re not from the area and I feel like if there are any other “out-of-towners” looking for a good bite but are having trouble finding a place, it’s worth taking a chance...

This is literally the most unprofessional pizza shop on the planet. I ordered a pizza at 6:45 and it is now 9:30 and I still have no pizza. I called at 7:45 and they said that the delivery was out. I called at 8:45 and they said that the drivers car broke down and that someone had to pick him up. They said to expect my pizza shortly. I called again at 9:25 and asked for an eta and they hung up on me. I called at 9:30 and they won’t answer because they’re closed. Do not go here. Do not order. I am LITERALLY down the road. I am a 15 minute walk away but it is dark and I can’t see very well so I ordered in. Huge mistake! If I had known, I would have ordered something else but unfortunately, I made the mistake of expecting professionalism and being patient and understanding. I tried to call again at 9:35, 9:37 and 9:40 to cancel my order (in the OFF chance that the delivery guy is on his way) and they wouldn’t pick up the phone. It’s not that hard to...