Paul's Pizza — Restaurant in Castleton

Paul’s pizza is a great choice for when you don’t want to cook. For the pizza and fried foods, the salads are pretty good too. I don’t like there grinders though, something about the bread just isn’t good. The lettuce was gross on it.

Pizzas are usually what we get. Sometimes we get excellent pizzas other times we get over cooked crappy pizzas. I order with light sauce because they plaster the pizza with too much sauce. Maybe some people may like it but my family does not. Fair prices though for when you get a good order. I have Facebook messaged them before over a really bad pizza and they made new ones and delivered it promptly. So there’s good and bad. I get being busy but we receive more over cooked pizzas than I could count. But we still order cause most the times it’s good.

This is a mixed review I know. We like Paul’s but aren’t always happy with it but hey we didn’t want to cook. It’s also one of the only places that deliver to fairhaven.

Good place but if I had other delivery options I wish we had a dominos...

Staying at Lake Bomoseen Lodge and wanted a quick lunch. Really happy with Paul's. Got a large pepperoni and large bacon with pineapple. Totally worth it. A lot of pizza places leave the crust as an afterthought but this place nailed it. So good, crunchy and a nice saltiness but not overdone. The sauce was perfect, not too sweet. And the toppings were great. Pepperoni had some nice heat. Bacon and pineapple prepared in nice even portions...not big lazy chunks. Great cheese. If I come back this way I'd definitely grab pizza here again. Just note that Google shows an old menu, so be sure to find the...

We are traveling from out of state, staying at the Bomoseen KOA. We had ordered at seven pm, said it'd be ready between 745-8 pm. Their website said they closed at 8, and so we arrived at 750. We were told it would be about 10 more minutes. Ended up being almost 25 minutes. Staff was friendly, restaurant looked nice and inviting. Pizza was a little dough in the middle, under cooked. When you picked up a slice it would fall apart. We ordered 2 large pizzas, antipasto salad and a fried calzone. Calzone was great, pizza and small let down to what we are used to. It might be a regional...