Sweet Shop — Restaurant in Eagles Mere

My wife and I had lunch there yesterday. The sandwiches my wife and I had consisted of some not very good turkey meat and cheese jammed between two pieces of toasted bread, also with some sort of spread. Thinking that a pastry might at least be ok, we split a “scone” which was not fresh and about on a par with the regrettable sandwich. This may be a fine place to get ice cream. I know it has a long and distinguished past as a distinguished ice cream stop. For a...

The Sweet Shop in Eagles Mere is a must stop spot for good sandwiches, specialty drinks, ice cream and much more! The sandwiches pictured below were the gourmet Philly, sweet turkey and Southwest BLT and they were all delicious! You can stay inside as there is plenty of seating with charming decorum from Sullivan County's past or hang out on the patio next to their water feature and neighborhood frogs 🐸 I can't wait until my next trip home from Korea to visit the...

We've now been here several times. The staff is always pleasant and helpful. The food delicious. Little one likes the Italian wrap. Husband loves the Turkey Club sandwich. I love the coffee brisket sandwich. Yum!!

From 2020: It was my little boy's first time ordering his own ice cream and he was So Excited. They were so great about counting out the change back to him.

Thank you for being so kind and patient ! We will see...