HTML SitemapExplore

Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs — Restaurant in Florida

Name
Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs
Description
Casual restaurant offering NY-style pizzas, subs & pastas, with delivery available.
Nearby attractions
Nearby restaurants
Nearby local services
St Nicholas Greek Orthodox Church
2525 S 25th St, Fort Pierce, FL 34981, United States
fort pierce greek festival
2525 S 25th St, Fort Pierce, FL 34981
Nearby hotels
Related posts
Keywords
Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs tourism.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs hotels.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs bed and breakfast. flights to Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs attractions.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs restaurants.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs local services.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs travel.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs travel guide.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs travel blog.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs pictures.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs photos.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs travel tips.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs maps.Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs things to do.
Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs
United StatesFloridaGoodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs

Basic Info

Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs

2993 S 25th St, Fort Pierce, FL 34981
4.0(482)$$$$
Open until 10:00 PM
order
order
order
Order
delivery
Save
spot

Ratings & Description

Info

Casual restaurant offering NY-style pizzas, subs & pastas, with delivery available.

attractions: , restaurants: , local businesses: St Nicholas Greek Orthodox Church, fort pierce greek festival
logoLearn more insights from Wanderboat AI.
Phone
(772) 465-6525
Website
goodfellaspizzaonline.com
Open hoursSee all hours
Wed10 AM - 10 PMOpen

Plan your stay

hotel
Pet-friendly Hotels in Florida
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Affordable Hotels in Florida
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.
hotel
Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Florida
Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Featured dishes

View full menu
dish
Jersey Shore Fries
dish
Homemade Garlic Knots
dish
Buffalo Chicken Salad Pizza
dish
White Pizza
dish
Steak Supreme Pizza
dish
BBQ Chicken Pizza
dish
Taco Pizza
dish
Cheese Pizza 16"
dish
Caesar Salad
dish
Fried Chicken Salad
dish
Calzone Large
dish
Sausage, Peppers & Onions Hot Sub

Reviews

Live events

Clear Kayak Sunset Mangrove Tour in Fort Pierce
Clear Kayak Sunset Mangrove Tour in Fort Pierce
Wed, Jan 28 • 4:00 PM
Fort Pierce, Florida, 34949
View details
Adult Intro to Birding Classes - January 2026
Adult Intro to Birding Classes - January 2026
Sat, Jan 3 • 8:30 AM
195 9th St SE, 195 9th Street Southeast, Vero Beach, United States
View details
ProSource of Vero Beach Sidewalk Sale
ProSource of Vero Beach Sidewalk Sale
Mon, Jan 26 • 9:00 AM
1605 90th Avenue, Vero Beach, FL, United States, Florida 32966
View details

Nearby local services of Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs

St Nicholas Greek Orthodox Church

fort pierce greek festival

St Nicholas Greek Orthodox Church

St Nicholas Greek Orthodox Church

4.6

(63)

Click for details
fort pierce greek festival

fort pierce greek festival

4.5

(36)

Click for details
Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Wanderboat LogoWanderboat

Your everyday Al companion for getaway ideas

CompanyAbout Us
InformationAI Trip PlannerSitemap
SocialXInstagramTiktokLinkedin
LegalTerms of ServicePrivacy Policy

Get the app

© 2025 Wanderboat. All rights reserved.

Reviews of Goodfella's Pizza, Pasta & Subs

4.0
(482)
avatar
1.0
4y

Was so excited to eat a good Calzone an pizza before I started the night shift.. Chose this place on line. Placed a order at 2:05... At 4:16 still no food so we called the establishment. They said the driver had the wrong room number. Now why he didn't ask the front desk I have no idea. So I checked my Email to see if I had made a mistake. AND NO I DID NOT...So when when he finally showed up with our food. I said I thought it would be fair if he gave it to me half priced since it was 2 hours cold. He said NO WAY... SO WITH THAT SAID HIS TRUE CHARACTER AN BUISNESS ETHIC GOT THIS REVIEW... NOT THE FOOD... SO FOLKS READ YOUR REVIEWS DONT ORDER TAKE OUT FROM THIS PLACE THEY R NOTORIOUS FOR BEING LATE AN COLD FOOD AND BLAMING THE CUSTOMER.. HAVE A BLESSED DAY. To your response back from my review on your establishment. First off if I didn't have money to eat out I would not order 50$ worth of food.. I don't try to get ANYTHING FOR FREE.....AND YOU SHOW VERY POOR POOR CHARACTER MORALS AND CUSTOMER SERVICE SKILLS.. I LOVE THE WAY YOU DEFEND YOURSELF WHEN YOU KNOW AN YOUR DRIVER KNOWS BECAUSE I showed him the order an email with everything 100% correct. Whoever wrote the order information from the on line order wrote it wrong for the delivery guy..Now who that was I don't know your the boss be one an find out why you get bad reviews.. Your driver saw the email an had to agree it was correct.b So before you falsely accuse someone on line get your facts straight because I have mine straight.. No one wants to pay top dollar for food that is 2 hours late MY HIG QUESTION FOR YOU IS WOULD YOU ALLOW SOMEONE TO TREAT YOU AND TALK TO YOU LIKE YOU'VE TALKED TO ME. IM SURE YOU WOULD NOT...Were here working on your Power Plant an if you would of showed customer service skills an good moral behavior you probably would of had about 30 men an women eating at your establishment for the next 3 months. But you refuse to admit any wrong doing so I have no desire to do business with someone that is mentally too hot headed an arrogant to save a relationship with a potential bcustomer an possibly a new friend . So you have a blessed weekend and they do have customer service classes at a local community College.. Have a...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
3y

Have stopped ordering from this restaurant due to the poor experience I had the last time I did order from here because I was a regular customer ordering a minimum of twice A week and spending $30-60 each time an order was placed, which i know isn't a life changing purchase and I'm sure their doing just fine without my few pennies spent there but after a friend of mine recently told me about their terrible experience at this same location and how rude the staff and management was to them when asking for their order to be redone due to being made incorrectly it brought back the bad memories of my previous experience so I felt the urge to leave a review to assure others that the 1 star reviews you see posted here are all very likely beyond legitimate as well and the owner should be ashamed of the way he treats his customers, and should teach his employees that they should not offer a customer to have their food corrected and tell them they can call in a repeat new order at a timing of their choice on a day in the future to make the incorrectly made order right. I was assured by staff there would be a note in the computer saying I was owed 2 subs at no charge when I decided to eat there again and this was definitely not true and I was yelled at by owner/management and refused the offer I had been promised and I have vowed to never spend another dime here again, and NO! I was not trying to get a free meal like the owner repeatedly accuses other customers of when they receive a wrong order or are unsatisfied with the quality of the food purchased. Never...

   Read more
avatar
1.0
3y

I eat a Goodfellas quite a bit, is really close by my job. Tonight when I call the place my order for lunch I order a chef salad, when I ride the chef salad was a small chef salad and I wanted a large surf salad. I told Lisa the cashier that I wanted to make it a large chef salad, she handed my salad back to Sarah and walked away. I walk by the door and I happened to look up and see Sarah making my salad. She took my original salad and dumped it into the bigger container. She then picked up anything that didn't land in the container and put it on top. All of this was done bare handed, she them wiped her hands on her apron. Went to the meats and cut it up and put it on my salad. As she was walking myself out to the counter I asked her could I please look at it first. Lisa snatched it from her and said I will handle this, I told her it looks like she just sloppily piled everything on top. Lisa rudely stated " all she did was add more lettuce, that's all a bigger salad is". I said really and she said yes. I asked could I take a picture of the salad and she said sure. I then told her I would not be purchasing it. Lisa reply was "ok". I may be one person but I will be sure to share my experience with everyone I know.

It was my lunch break and I don't get off until late but I refuse to pay for bad service and...

   Read more
Page 1 of 7
Previous
Next

Posts

Bigg CleveBigg Cleve
I eat a Goodfellas quite a bit, is really close by my job. Tonight when I call the place my order for lunch I order a chef salad, when I ride the chef salad was a small chef salad and I wanted a large surf salad. I told Lisa the cashier that I wanted to make it a large chef salad, she handed my salad back to Sarah and walked away. I walk by the door and I happened to look up and see Sarah making my salad. She took my original salad and dumped it into the bigger container. She then picked up anything that didn't land in the container and put it on top. All of this was done bare handed, she them wiped her hands on her apron. Went to the meats and cut it up and put it on my salad. As she was walking myself out to the counter I asked her could I please look at it first. Lisa snatched it from her and said I will handle this, I told her it looks like she just sloppily piled everything on top. Lisa rudely stated " all she did was add more lettuce, that's all a bigger salad is". I said really and she said yes. I asked could I take a picture of the salad and she said sure. I then told her I would not be purchasing it. Lisa reply was "ok". I may be one person but I will be sure to share my experience with everyone I know. It was my lunch break and I don't get off until late but I refuse to pay for bad service and bad quality.
Kristine GibsonKristine Gibson
Completely disappointment! I just ordered and received my delivery and all was well until I OPENED my pizza box 😳. It was a complete mess. The cheese practically came off the half the pizza to and all over the box, the pizza was soggy to the point of falling apart when I tried to pick it up and overall inedible. After spending my money I ended up having to throw it out and call another place for pizza. A complete wast of money. *In response to the owner* It's not BS. Unfortunately that's what i recieved. That's why I added a picture. Instead of being rude you should offer an apology to a customer who had a horrible experience with your pizza. It was INEDIBLE and soggy. I would've been tempted to order again but not delivery. However after your nasty comment I hope people stear clear of your business.
TaharahTaharah
Lil man enjoys pizza, cheese and veggie to be exact. So like an amazing mom, I wanted to fulfill his love of pizza. While visiting family in Fort Pierce, my uncle told me about Goodfellas. So my little man and I decided to give it a try. The one we went to is in a small strip next to a gas station. The place offers indoor seating and huge slices of pizza!! They didn't have veggie available at the time, so Lil man ended up with cheese, and I got a steak and cheese stuffed roll. At first sight I thought my child can't eat all that....boy was I wrong. He ate the entire slice. I loved my stuffed it was sooooo cheesy and they did not skimp on the steak. I will definitely be back.
See more posts
See more posts
hotel
Find your stay

Pet-friendly Hotels in Florida

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

I eat a Goodfellas quite a bit, is really close by my job. Tonight when I call the place my order for lunch I order a chef salad, when I ride the chef salad was a small chef salad and I wanted a large surf salad. I told Lisa the cashier that I wanted to make it a large chef salad, she handed my salad back to Sarah and walked away. I walk by the door and I happened to look up and see Sarah making my salad. She took my original salad and dumped it into the bigger container. She then picked up anything that didn't land in the container and put it on top. All of this was done bare handed, she them wiped her hands on her apron. Went to the meats and cut it up and put it on my salad. As she was walking myself out to the counter I asked her could I please look at it first. Lisa snatched it from her and said I will handle this, I told her it looks like she just sloppily piled everything on top. Lisa rudely stated " all she did was add more lettuce, that's all a bigger salad is". I said really and she said yes. I asked could I take a picture of the salad and she said sure. I then told her I would not be purchasing it. Lisa reply was "ok". I may be one person but I will be sure to share my experience with everyone I know. It was my lunch break and I don't get off until late but I refuse to pay for bad service and bad quality.
Bigg Cleve

Bigg Cleve

hotel
Find your stay

Affordable Hotels in Florida

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Get the Appoverlay
Get the AppOne tap to find yournext favorite spots!
Completely disappointment! I just ordered and received my delivery and all was well until I OPENED my pizza box 😳. It was a complete mess. The cheese practically came off the half the pizza to and all over the box, the pizza was soggy to the point of falling apart when I tried to pick it up and overall inedible. After spending my money I ended up having to throw it out and call another place for pizza. A complete wast of money. *In response to the owner* It's not BS. Unfortunately that's what i recieved. That's why I added a picture. Instead of being rude you should offer an apology to a customer who had a horrible experience with your pizza. It was INEDIBLE and soggy. I would've been tempted to order again but not delivery. However after your nasty comment I hope people stear clear of your business.
Kristine Gibson

Kristine Gibson

hotel
Find your stay

The Coolest Hotels You Haven't Heard Of (Yet)

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

hotel
Find your stay

Trending Stays Worth the Hype in Florida

Find a cozy hotel nearby and make it a full experience.

Lil man enjoys pizza, cheese and veggie to be exact. So like an amazing mom, I wanted to fulfill his love of pizza. While visiting family in Fort Pierce, my uncle told me about Goodfellas. So my little man and I decided to give it a try. The one we went to is in a small strip next to a gas station. The place offers indoor seating and huge slices of pizza!! They didn't have veggie available at the time, so Lil man ended up with cheese, and I got a steak and cheese stuffed roll. At first sight I thought my child can't eat all that....boy was I wrong. He ate the entire slice. I loved my stuffed it was sooooo cheesy and they did not skimp on the steak. I will definitely be back.
Taharah

Taharah

See more posts
See more posts