Old Shell Store - Kitchen & Taphouse — Restaurant in Greybull

ICE CREAM SANDWICH HEAVEN !!! Stopped in because we heard from folks in Greybull that the homemade ice cream sandwiches were as big as a dinner plate and really yummy. Honestly, I didn’t have high expectations, I mean - how much room is there for a remarkable experience for a frozen ice cream sandy? Well, I chose the chocolate chip cookie and vanilla ice cream option (there are many). It’s huge - but it’s also shockingly amazing. The cookie top and bottom aren’t hard or too soft, they are perfect. The ice cream is perfectly soft too - but not dripping. I don’t know how they do it but it’s masterful. I ate that ice cream sandwich, even sharing bites of it - on FOUR different occasions. Putting it back in the freezer of our RV and then back home - with its original plastic wrapping after having a sweet treat over several days. I will tell everyone to go get these!!! So FUN...

Baked Goods! Yes, the food is amazing. Best fried chicken I've had since I lived in the south for a few years. Burgers are amazing. Sweet potatoe fries are the best version of themselves. But the baked goods.... are some of the best I've ever had. I've even been to Buddy's bakery in NJ (Cake Boss) but the stuff here might beat it. The buttercream frosting cookie sandwiches may be the crown jewel here but these baked goods need a social media presence of their own, it's insane. I'd go on but if I do youll think I'm setting the bar too high and there's no way and you won't believe me so please, just go in and get a cookie or piece of cake or anything else....

We just stopped in here because it looked like a cool place when we were driving by. They had many souvenirs, snacks, beer and a restaurant. Decided to get something to eat and I am so glad we did! Everything is made fresh with a wood burning grill, the hamburger and French fries were out of this word and their chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich was homemade and the best I ever had! This is a must stop if you are in the area as you go right by it if you are traveling on Route 14 on your way to Greybull! The bonus was it was a beautiful day and they both indoor and also outdoor seating so you can enjoy the day! ...