Hole in the Wall — Restaurant in Gwynn's Island

Four of us went in this past Saturday afternoon and sat at the bar for lunch and drinks. The place was packed and the staff (including one of the owners) was working together like a well oiled machine. As two huge groups were sat we were recommended to order in stages so we complied. We sampled the Bloody Mary shrimp salsa (which was piled high with shrimp) were quickly probed as to how it was. We explained to the bar manager that although the shrimp were plentiful we would have liked more of the salsa. Before we could have another sample, another container of salsa (only) appeared along with requested hot sauce and we mopped up the remainder of the appetizer. After another frosty cold beverage three of us decided on the grilled grouper tacos and the fourth had the shrimp basket with fries. While waiting for our food, we must have seen at least 30 tacos come out of the kitchen. When our food arrived, we quickly found out why. The grouper was awesome, cooked to perfection with the perfect toppings. The shrimp basket was delicious and the cole slaw tasted freshly made. The short time we waited allowed us time to visit with the other patrons at the bar ( a nice mix of folks both new to Mathews coming here to our county for the first time, and long time property owners). I would definitely recommend coming here. For an establishment only being open a week, it is very impressive to see the owners and staff work together in the manner they do and striving to make The Hole In The Wall even better than it already is. After enjoying the great food and views, we enjoyed a large group of dolphins playing around us as we cruised our boat...

I wanted so badly to like this place because it was highly recommended by locals. I think we caught it on an off day but this was a pretty bad experience. We waited for a table which was fine because we needed a high chair and couldn’t do a high top. It wasn’t a long wait. Our waiter took 15 minutes to get our drink order, another 5-10 to get an appetizer in, and I had to stop him from walking away a 3rd time to put in our food. Our food took over an hour, maybe an hour and a half to come out. Our waiter only came to give us an update when him and I finally made eye contact and I guess he could sense I was getting annoyed. We were trying to enjoy the time there as it was a nice view, but watching everyone else get their food was pretty frustrating especially for our 2 year old. When I got my food, I had eaten half my sandwich before I realized they had left the plastic wax paper in between my sandwich. I mentioned this to to our waiter who explained that should not have happened and offered me a free dessert, which I appreciated. I was so irritated at this point and our kid was well past his bed time, we boxed up our food...

A hidden gem. It was busy both days we went, but the service and food was on spot. Our second visit, we brought our pup and utilized outside dining. The raw Oysters were plump and succulent. The OBX shrimp were jumbo, firm, and off the chain. The Maui Maui (blackened) was on point. I used to eat at the eatery here back in the 70's and 80's. I understand this business has been at this "historic site" for 5 yrs now. Congratulations!!! Y'all have out down yourselves and I understand they are expanding; a second location in Gloucester Point. It's great to see the great success they've brought to the island, just across the bridge, at the boat landing. You won't be disappointed. Casual dress, very friendly atmosphere and views of the bay make your dining experience so very pleasurable. Definitely coming back more often! My grandfather used to drop his boats in, at the landing for many many years, and we always ate at the eatery that is now The Hole in the Wall! Authentic Island experience right there! Go and enjoy! Experience a great time with friends and family...welcome to Gwynn's Island's The Hole in the Wall "Gem of...