IL Nonno Pizza — Restaurant in Halfway

Every time I would log on to DoorDash, Il Nonno would show as a suggestion based on my past orders. I have to say… I am SO happy that I took a chance and ordered delivery from them.

It is so difficult to find really good New York style pizza in the Washington County area. Il Nonno is the closest that I have found! It tastes great, and the crust is spectacular as well. As far as the subs- they were just as tasty! I love the sub rolls that they use. They are perfectly toasted on the outside, and soft and chewy on the inside. Exactly how I like mine!

I am unable to rate/comment on the atmosphere or service, as I have never been to the restaurant in person. However- from the time that I placed my order, and the order being delivered… it was less than 45 minutes. I assume that service is top notch as well for me to have gotten my order as quickly as I did.

I am beyond pleased with everything that I got from Il Nonno, and I now consider this restaurant my go-to when it comes to ordering...

I haven’t been home to NY in years, and living in Maryland, it’s been nearly impossible to find a pizzeria that truly knows how to make authentic NY pizza — that perfect balance of flavor with a thin, crunchy crust. But Il Nonno Pizza absolutely nailed it! 🍕

From the very first bite, I felt like I was back in New York. The crust has that signature crunch without being overdone, the sauce is rich and flavorful, and the cheese is perfectly melted with just the right stretch. They truly know what they’re doing here!

Beyond the incredible pizza, the atmosphere is spotless — you can tell they take pride in keeping their space clean and welcoming. The customer service is exceptional; every staff member I’ve interacted with has been friendly, attentive, and genuinely happy to be there.

If you’re searching for the real deal NY-style pizza in Maryland, look no further — Il Nonno Pizza is hands-down the best! I’m so glad I found them, and I’ll definitely be back...

Il Nonno Pizza isn’t just food—it’s an experience. The moment I took that first bite, I felt like I was back in New York. The crust? Perfectly thin and crisp with just the right chew. The sauce? Bursting with flavor. The cheese? Melted perfection. It’s the kind of pizza that wakes up your soul and reminds you what real pizza is supposed to taste like.

On top of the amazing food, the customer experience is perfect—quick, friendly, and genuinely nice people who make you feel welcome the second you walk in. I’ve tried a lot of pizza places, but this one brought me back to life. Every bite took me home, and I left with a full stomach and a big smile. If you’re looking for true New York-style pizza, ll Nonno is...