Old Mill Pizzeria — Restaurant in Hamilton Township

The Old Mill Pizza is Family owned, very hard working and it shows they cook with ❤️ love. Service is impeccable. I stopped in and noticed the ownership/management & staff had completely changed for the best I've ever seen here. It appeared to be a family working together- mother/father/daughter combination, like how pizza places used to be growing up. They spoke kindly to customers as well as to each other. They took my order and brought my food out to me at the table. Everyone seemed happy and very pleasant, what a great atmosphere they've created. They did this for everyone, at booths or in dining area. Everything looks so cleaned up and brighter inside. You could eat off the floor and sink top in the bathroom & smelled fresh like fruit. A definite change. Let's talk about the food now...It was lunchtime, so I ordered 2 plain slices and a side of garlic knots to go. It was tempting to order the Sicilian slices as they looked so pretty and fresh on the countertop. I hadn't seen true New York style Sicilian look that good around here for a while. The slices were cut from a freshly made pie and looked delicious and were served hot. Not sitting around in a case on the countertop for hours like other places I've been to locally. The sauce was thick and flavorful and not Watered down. The crust wasn't too thick & wasn't too thin, just right. Cheese was perfect not too much, not too little. 😋 All the spices were filled, fresh and containers were all clean. Plenty of napkins on every table top. The woman whom took my order was very polite and offered plenty of time to look over the menu which was very professional looking, with large enough writing and a beautiful display of colors and pics to persuade me to want to try everything. The prices were average reasonable and there were plenty of choices for everyone in your family, from salads, pizzas, entrees, sides and lots more. Don't worry if your loyal to a brand of drink Pepsi or coke etc. They have a soda fountain and a cooler full of bottled sodas cans and other soft drinks to go or stay. Plenty of real drinking straws too! I give it 2 yummy thumbs up as it's now added to my regular route of food stops now. Don't hesitate to dine in or call ahead as I saw them answering the phone on the first ring, unlike past owners, whom would let it ring off the hook! It's refreshing to see a family run style pizza 🍕 place still exists locally. I will update this post with more photos as I will definitely visit again and again in the future. Thank you for all your hard work and kindness it shows and is...

I was truly pleasantly surprised by this place, and I had a wonderful slice of grandma pizza when I stopped by one day after working a job in the area. Typically I don’t think of Stroudsburg as an area in which I can get good quality pizza, but this little place Is worth a visit. Don’t be put off if there is no other cars in the parking lot. It reflects the ZIP Code not the food for sure. I don’t typically try places where I don’t see other diners, but I gave this place a chance, and I’m glad I did. The grandma pie as I said was delicious, they add small drizzles of pesto, a slight variation from most. But I thought it tasted great! The crust was not too thick, slight crunch to it, cheese melted on top nicely, And the sauce was hearty and exactly how grandma sauce should taste. I could tell it was fresh as well, it wasn’t prior day pizza or anything. The owners there are extremely nice, I chatted with them for a couple minutes. They obviously care about their customers, and I truly respect the product they put out what with the challenges having a business in that area. Kudos to you! Also, the place is super clean and the atmosphere is lovely. I just thought they deserved...

Now, I’m really never one to complain but you can’t up your prices on your customers and then put less toppings… i.e. myself who orders from here weekly… I paid 36 dollars for a small CBR pizza and a large plain pie.. I did call, and a new pizza to be maid was offered but that isn’t an option for me as I work overnights and I need to get ready, so I don’t have the time to wait for another pizza to be made… I feel bad leaving this but, truly, I’m disappointed, I wasn’t offered any other solution… I won’t...