Fosters Tavern of Hinckley — Restaurant in Hinckley Township

We had a party of 8, 4 couples. Between all of us we ordered 6 appetizers, 2 pizzas, 3 fish dinners and an order of pierogi's. Two people in our party received their order a good 15-20 minutes before the rest of the group. They had both ordered fish so it had to be eaten when it came out. They could not wait for the rest of us to get our meals. The appetizers and pizza were all good. All 3 people that had gotten the fish dinners agreed that it was just ok, not great. They did end up eating it though. I was the person that ordered the pierogi's. The first time they came out they were cold and one entire side of all of them had absolutely no color to them. I asked the waitress if I could please get them redone. I did have high expectations since it was $15 for 6 pierogi's. When they were returned to me they were hot, however they still were very pale looking on one side. In my opinion that showed that they were just put in the microwave to warm them up. I decided to try them anyway and did not like them at all . They were very bland and rubbery. I told the waitress and sent them back. The owner then came out to speak to me and I told her everything that I stated in this review. She left saying she was going to speak to the cook. The owner never returned to my table. She instead made the poor young lady who waited on us, inform me that I would be paying for the pierogi's that I had returned. I find this to be poor service from the owner on so many levels. The only thing that was 100% fantastic was our waitress Kennedi. I would not recommend stopping...

I had ordered my burger medium rare. When it came out it was rare IMO. So I sent it back. Francesca, our server couldn’t have been nicer about it. I had taken two bites before I decided I just couldn’t do it. I told her to nuke it a minute and it would be perfect. They completely redid the burger, bringing a new one out. I couldn’t believe they did that. A lot of places just send you the same product out, and usually overcooked. 😖. Not in this case. Francesca couldn’t have been nicer and more attentive. The burger and fries were awesome. You could tell it was made from fresh ground beef and not some preformed frozen patties. The toppings were all fresh and packed high. I had to mash the heck out of it to get it in my mouth. The fries were awesome as well. Done just right. My wife’s burger was cooked to perfection. (She likes well done) and she had hush puppies which were very tasty. I had a cup of clam chowder to try and it too was exceptional. Large chucks of clams in a super tasty broth with celery and carrot. I highly recommend stopping by and trying them for yourself. We will stop by anytime...

Long time customer. I tried to call repeatedly to order pizza today. I could not get through. Since I was driving by on the way home I stopped in to order pizza. I was asked by an older male who I believe was an owner, if he could help me.

I complained that I called repeatedly, but could not get through. I was told that they only do call ahead orders since they are so busy. I replied that has never been a problem in the past. Further more, If one can not get through, how the hell does one call ahead!?

I replied that I'll have to take my business elsewhere if I can not get through to place an order. The person replied very rudely that they don't need my business. I said fine and walked out.

They pizza is decent but not the same or as good as it was with the previous owners. The new owners skimp on toppings and have made the pizzas smaller and thinner to save a few cents. The pizza is still good, but less of it.

I am saddened that I'll have to find a new pizza shop to buy pizza. I can not go back there after being...