Xtrordinary Pizza — Restaurant in Indianapolis

I called and placed my order and mentioned that I had never been there or order from them before. I asked about pricing and how they did their pizzas. They told me I could get a supreme for a certain price. But I didn't want a supreme so I asked about a meat lovers and it was the same price. However I did not realize that the price is the same no matter what toppings you give on it so I only got three toppings instead of what I normally would have gotten if I had knownI could have had as many toppings as I wanted.

The pricing though easy for them is a bit confusing to me. For example their prices include tax, and they do free delivery, but they charge a dollar for credit card use which they never told me about even after they charged me for it. It isn't listed anywhere that I saw and wasn't on their menu either. I had a debit card I could have used if I had known..

Pizza crust was very thin almost like cardboard, but really more like cardstock. I'm not exaggerating. It bothered me that the crust was one of those pre-made pizza crust that you can buy at a grocery store for a couple bucks. It wasn't made out of fresh dough or even frozen dough. The sauce was good. It was a little sweet but not too sweet. However it quickly made the crust soggy. The cheese was rubbery and I believe was probably made with all skim milk cheese oh, but I'm not for certain about that. The toppings were piled high but they only offer 9 choices and they do not have many choices that I would have had on my pizza such as bacon. The edges of the pizza were very burnt, but that probably was because of how much toppings there were and how much it had to cook in the center.

There were also no seats to sit and wait for your pizza until it was finished. Though this didn't necessarily bother me, it should be noted that no hairnets nor gloves were used in the preparation of food and since it wasn't a Ready-to-Eat product it is legal to do what they did.

All in all, we will not be ordering again. From Domino's you can get three pizzas for the price of one here with many more options like bacon, chicken, hamburger, pineapple, different sauces, real crust, and more. It almost pains me to say it but I would have preferred a Little Caesars pizza or even a DiGiorno pizza compared to this. My wife, who has been begging me to order from here, after eating two pieces asked if it was okay if we could give the rest...

This place is AMAZING! Saturday night was my first visit. My buddy drove me up there to pick up our pizza.... he turned into a driveway and I asked, "Bro! Where the 'H' are ya goin!?" He didn't answer, just kept driving. Around one building, and between two others. By this time, I was positive that he'd either gotten lost, or just lost his mind! Then, all of a sudden....we pull up to this small, incredibly unassuming looking building. I quickly realized where we were. But STILL! I flat out asked him.... What kinda dump did u order our pizza from! There was only one other car there, that I had to assume belonged to an employee. He says, 'just wait'. We go inside. I see the most BEAUTIFUL woman on the phone taking an order. When shes able to, she tells us it would be about 10 mins, and quickly returns to the phone. By the time our pizza was ready, 7 other people had come to pick up their food. One of the guys had to jump on the phone so she could take care of us. They were SLAMMED! She STAYED busy on that phone the entire time we were there! But, no matter how busy she was...she took the time to greet us, have a quick friendly conversation, and asked us to "please come back! " Her attitude was just as beautiful as she was! Little did I know, the best was yet to come. THAT PIZZA WAS RIDICULOUS! It was SOOO BIG! And DELICIOUS! Listen y'all, if your really hungry, have a house full, or just want a movie night at home with your family... I highly recommend this place! It's a little more expensive than the major pizzerias, but WELL WORTH IT! You will not be...

As a small business owner myself, and a 40 yr resident of Wanamaker, I am completely blown away at my interaction with your business and extremely disappointed Brian that you see no problem. We completely understand and know that Friday night is an extremely busy time for you, which is why after 3 members of the family could not reach you by phone after 30 minutes, and I was driving in from TN, decided I would arrive at your business, place our order and expect to wait another 1 hour. However, as I arrived several people were leaving upset and with pink flyers. I went inside and excited to see familiar faces only to be greeted with "we don't take counter orders, and handed a pink flyer." I continue to stand there as she took phone orders and once had her attention said, I literally just drove in here and can't believe you won't take an order when I am standing right here....and yes I was loud. Brian your response that this is how you do business was shocking. Why would you turn away business? Someone is there willing to order and pay and wait...that is how much they enjoy your product and your response was you have to call? I have known you my whole life and my mother is still a well known resident in Wanamaker. We will NEVER patron your business again. We wish you the best of continued success, but hope you change your way so that others who may have not experienced this great pizza does not have to experience what a...