Tiki Bar — Restaurant in Islamorada

We were pleasantly surprised how good the food was at Amara Cay! Our son and his wife had lunch at the Tiki Bar and loved it! We had dinner with our friends and the food was excellent. The fried calamari was perfectly cooked and the shrimp BLT was huge. We asked if the chef would make the tuna bowls (only on the lunch menu) for us at dinner. They were absolutely delicious! Our waiter was new, but such a nice young man. He was very attentive and made sure we were well taken care of! This was...

Where do I even begin! PAPPPIIII [Alton], Ebner, Patrick. You were all phenomenal! We had so much fun with you three. So many laughs and stories. You guys made me the best virgin drinks! [it's not the same not having them everyday] The views while sitting at the tiki bar are soooo wonderful! Don + Dawn, made us out of towners feel like locals! We ordered apps while at the tiki bar and they were excellent! Jason bought out our food and was so kind and thoughtful. Thank you Tiki Bar staff! We miss...

You don’t have any other options if you don’t want to leave the pool. So do you leave or order from the Tiki bar? Skip the burger. We did nachos twice (the pool is in fact amazing). The first time we got the nachos the minimal cheese was burnt to a literal crisp. The second time we combated this by ordering extra cheese! If you get a decent breakfast the nachos can hold you over until dinner. Don’t waste your money on...