Byler`s Family Restaurant — Restaurant in Jamestown

We had seen an ad online for Byler's and decided to take a drive and check the place out. We arrived a little before they opened and so took a pretty drive along Pymatuming Lake. Once we went in, we were graciously greeted and seated, and attended to by Marie, our waitress. She could not have been more friendly and pleasant and made us feel welcome. She answered all our questions about the menu. First, she brought some freshly baked rolls with apple butter and whipped peanut butter to tide us over until our meal was ready. Delicious! I chose the fried chicken, and it did not disappoint! The breading was thin, crispy and very well-seasoned without being overpowering. It was fried perfectly crisp with no greasiness, and was so moist and tender inside. Even the breast was juicy. I also ordered the Mac & Cheese as a side, and it was creamy and rich. There was plenty for my sweetie and I to share. He ordered the Roast Beef Sandwich and it was outstanding. The beef was so tender it fell apart in your mouth, and the gravy was homemade - not the bagged or bottled stuff you usually get. The mashed potatoes were perhaps the creamiest and fluffiest I have ever eaten. The owner visited for awhile, and even offered some bites of their steak which we both agreed was seasoned and cooked to perfection. We came home with Apple Crumble and Butterscotch pie, which was the icing on the cake, so to speak. Their prices are quite reasonable, especially for the level of quality of the food and service we received. If traveling to Pymatuming or in the Jamestown area, be sure and give them a try. We will definitely be back! Thank you...

A Delightful Taste of Amish Tradition

Rating: ★★★★★

Bylers Family Restaurant is an absolute gem! From the moment you step inside, you are greeted with the warm, homey atmosphere that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience. The charm of Amish culture is evident in every detail, from the rustic decor to the friendly, attentive staff.

The food is nothing short of amazing. Every dish we tried was a testament to the rich culinary traditions of the Amish community. The homemade bread and butter were the perfect start to our meal, fresh and flavorful. We couldn't get enough of the juice, well cooked ribeye steak and ribs, packed with flavor and perfectly made mashed potatoes and delicious gravy. The chicken fingers, stuffing, salad were another standout, with perfectly fried coating on the chicken fresh food and savory.

Don't even get me started on the desserts! The pie was the best I've ever had, and the ice cream was simply divine. It's clear that everything is made with love and the freshest ingredients. Thank you for a wonderful evening spike! With love,...

The food is sooooooo good. I couldn't eat it all, my husband couldn't even eat it all. For him to have to take home a carry out there had to be great big portions. Great prices. I have gone here three times this week all my husbands idea. The first time was our anniversary and they gave my a free dessert. The second time we took our grandson, he has Celiac disease and has to eat gluten free I explained it to the waitress, the owner came over and everyone knew what that was and they made him gluten free gravy and made him a special meal we all are the gravy and it was so good we never missed the gluten at all. This is our new favorite...