Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop — Restaurant in Lake Mills

We organized an Elsie Mae Pie fundraiser for our school right before Thanksgiving, which, as you can imagine, is a hectic time and quite a challenge to manage a school full of orders. We encountered a few bumps along the way, but Paul truly went the extra mile to ensure the fundraiser was a huge success! He was fantastic to work with and an all-around wonderful person! The feedback from our school community has been overwhelmingly positive, with everyone raving about how delicious the pies are! Thank you for bringing such a delightful treat to our holiday...

Sad to see they are temp closed. The donuts were good when we could get them on the weekends. Usually sell out quickly, which is understandable. Smaller place but a good variety of items. We liked everything we tried, enjoyed having the small pie options to try a variety of them. Didn't try any mixes or other store offerings. If the location was more central to the downtown, I think they would do way more business and be more known, the location is hidden within an...

Bought one of their adorable little apple pies at the Waukesha Farmer's market and finally got around to taking a bite out of it and wow... pies can and do vary wildly, some are too sweet, some are too tart, some have pie crists too crunchy some have pie crusts that seem underbaked.. but this... this was smack dab in the goldilocks zone. This is the kind of pie I always hope for when trying a different bakery's...