Out of the Blue - Coffee and Ice cream — Restaurant in Milltown

If you're ever wandering through Milltown and in need of a cozy spot to unwind, run (don’t walk!) to this adorable little coffee shop tucked beside the river and waterfall near the blue bridge. It’s the kind of place that feels like it was pulled straight from a 70’s small-town love story—a little slice of calm and nostalgia with a whole lot of charm.

From the moment I walked in, I felt like I stepped into another era. The decor is quaint and heartwarming, with vintage touches and historical photographs of Milltown from 1915 that connect you to the soul of the area. There’s something so special about sipping your coffee while surrounded by such rich local history—it feels like the shop itself is telling you a story.

The atmosphere? Peaceful. The service? Quick and warm. Even on Easter Sunday, they were open (surprise!) and welcoming. I had the pleasure of chatting with Sherry, the store owner, who radiates kindness and genuinely cares about her customers. Whether you're local or just passing through, she makes you feel like you're exactly where you belong.

Oh, and the location is everything. With views of the nearby waterfall and the gentle sounds of water in the background, it’s the perfect little nook to relax with a drink, a good book, or someone you love.

Whether you're a coffee connoisseur, an ice cream lover, or a nature-loving bookworm, this spot has something for you. I truly hope more people discover it, fall in love with it, and help keep this magical little place thriving. 🌿☕📚

Highly recommend. 10/10...

Stopped in yesterday & hot and got an Iced Smores Latte. It was soooo tasty. It is a very nice clean coffee shop,the ice cream all looked good. The lady working the counter was very nice& friendly. Couldn't decide between 2 different ones asked her for her suggestion & she suggested the Smores Latte . When you passing through on highway 64 detour in to Milltown & check them out,you...

Great place to cool down on a hot summer day the portions were very ample with lots of flavors to choose from We went here after going on cave country canoes with I would highly recommend for any...