Crossroads II Pizza & Subs — Restaurant in New Berlin

Just moved into the area, and wanted to try a local pizza place. Since I passed this on the way to work, it was an easy choice.

First off, be warned that they do not take credit cards. They do accept checks or cash, and also have an ATM on site.

We ordered via phone and went to pick it up. Two large pizzas, one pepperoni and one with pineapple and black olives. They seemed real nice on the phone.

When we arrived, that's when we learned they don't accept credit cards. We did have the checkbook, so all's well. Pizza was hot, ready, and boxed at the time they said it would be.

Got home, opened the boxes, and the pizzas looked pretty good, but I noted a lot of cheese on the pineapple and olive pizza. The pepperoni looked fine though. The crust on each pizza was thicker than other thin crusts I was used to, but that is of no fault to anyone, and it was still thin and crispy.

Taste wise, there was nothing wrong with the pizzas. They were tasty, great balance of sauce and crust. Where I got hung up was on the amount of cheese on the pineapple and olive pizza. The pieces were difficult to pull apart, and often the cheese was so thick that pulling slices apart often caused the toppings on the slice I wanted to stay attached to the rest of the pizza, only leaving me with the crust and sauce. Using a pizza cutter to get through the cheese was my only option to get complete slices.

The pepperoni didn't have this issue, and I'd say that one was great.

For the money, I'd say that the price is higher than others, but the pizzas were pretty large. I plan on giving them another shot with the pizza, and perhaps try their...

Listen up y'all. I just tried the Crossroads 6" Hoagie Sub Sandwich. Wow, it's surprisingly delish! I love my subs, but I wasn't sure about a Hoagie. So, the sausage/deli meat patty has a little spice to it, covered with Provolone cheese, green peppers, onions, and layer of Marinara sauce. Hey, and don't forget to have it toasted by Carl! So good... Update 7/30/23 - just tried the Italian Chicken Sub. It is a 6" sub, with breaded, oven- baked Chicken, lettuce, onions, tomatoes, and Provologne cheese, with a rich addition of mayo & Italian dressing. Mariana sauce is typically added, but I skipped that today. The oven baked chicken is soft and tender, the mayo & Italian Dressing are a great combo. This Chicken Italian Sub & dill pickle spear will fill your appetite. Other options include having it toasted, adding peppers and black or green olives or other cheese selections. Nov 2023 Update: Did you know that Crossroads now offers something for your sweet tooth: Pizza Cookies and Sprecher Sodas? I've tried their 3 Pizza Cookies: Chocolate Chip, Brownie and M & M Cookies. All are pretty good, but my fav is the Brownie. Just a nice blend of flavor and consistency, especially when these cookies pop out hot from your oven. And don't forget to grab your favorite Sprecher Root Beer or other flavors, like Cream soda, Orange Dreamcicle, Cherry Cola, Grape and Citrus. Finish off your delicious Crossroads pizza with some yummy sweets...fill...

Omg I was passing thru for work on my lunch break and decided to just Google the closet food to me. The customer service was great but the food is HORRIBLE!!! I ordered cheese curls and chicken tenders and omg it was so nasty!!! They didn’t even deep fry them they put them in the oven the oven only burnt a couple of sides on the tenders and cheese curls!!! The batter didn’t stick!!! It tasted like freezer burn. You can tell by the pictures they didn’t even try to cook it right I was very disappointed and it made my stomach hurt! I took one bite of the chicken tenders and soy it right back out and the cheese curls the same way!!! They said they’re known for having great pizza but I wouldn’t even purchase water from them SO DISAPPOINTED AND I RATE THEM A 0!! I really want a refund but instead I thru the plate out the window into the dumpster I found! That was my first time and last time EVER ordering from them! Thank god I don’t live on this side of town because this restaurant make me not wanna get anything in this town SHAME ON Y’ALL!!!...