The Original PJ's Pizza - New Martinsville — Restaurant in New Martinsville

Pizza is horrible! Visiting from Florida, so not familiar with places in area. First we call up and they say they only have dough for extra large and smalls, so we ordered an extra large white spinach pizza and a small pepperoni. The small pepperoni is the same size of a personal pan pizza at Pizza Hut (really small). The red sauce tastes like they just popped open a can of tomato sauce from the dollar store, no seasonings, really cheap. I've had better red sauce on a frozen pizza from the grocery store. The white pizza was a decent size, but it was basically a flavorless square of dough, no seasoning.

Over the phone they gave us one price, but when the driver got to the room she asked for more money and kept the receipt... pretty shady if you ask me. We definitely feel ripped off, would have felt better if we were just mugged in the street.

I don't know any of the other places in the area, but I wouldn't order from here if you don't have to....

I ordered takeout for the 2 days I was in town. To my surprise, they had gluten-free pizza and my huband had their philly cheese sub (and loved it!). The guy that answered the phone when I called in my order was knowledgeable and asked if it was an allergy, and I told him yes. I also ordered it without cheese, and without making me feel weird, he said Ok and within 20 mins, my pizza was done and delicious. I did order ranch on the side, and I think they homemade it because it was pretty watery looking but I tried it and it was delicious as well. I was really worried at first about ordering from here because it doesn't look super appealing but don't judge a book by its cover. This place is a must try! I will be visiting again next time...

How do I give a zero star review ! Ordered the pizza , sat outside for 30 minutes waiting for my time it was to be ready (30 minutes) but wife wanted pizza , I wait for pizza. I go to check in at the time the text told me it would be ready. They have never heard of me. Translation , my order hasn't been started. Their printer machine was turned off and that was their excuse. Customers don't pay for or eat excuses . So they start my order (30 more minutes). A hand full of other customers got the same excuse and waited , 15 minutes and served. But I'm not a regular so I was put on the bottom of the OOPS list even though I was first to discover the problem and waiting the longest. I cannot see how these will stay...