Dewey's Pizza - O'Fallon — Restaurant in O'Fallon

Went here for the first time today. I got an entree salad for myself, and my kids and husband shared the pizza. When I ordered for my kids, all I wanted was a plain cheese pizza, and was quite angry when receiving the bill that they charged 5.50 for extra cheese. Most of that "extra" cheese ended up stuck to the cardboard the pizza was brought out on. The regular fountain drinks were nowhere on the menu, so another shock seeing that each drink is charged 3.25. had we known that we would've just ordered water. The Caesar salad was good. The employees were all nice, including I'm assuming was the manager helping seat customers. However there isn't much conversation or connection there, just transactional. There were no signs for bathrooms that we could see, so held it until we left. Overall we ended up spending 70$ (not including tip) on 2 of the smallest pizzas, salad, and drinks. The prices are extortionate, and the extra charges were insanely high and something we weren't expecting, which took away from the tip we were able to leave unfortunately. We will probably not return due to the high prices, as we all felt the pizza was a little subpar. It was really cool that you could watch them make the pizzas, but that experience alone didn't justify the...

Stayed in the Hilton Garden in last night and thought we were out of luck for food being it was almost 9pm on a Sunday night. Looked across the street and saw the lights on at a pizza place. I was prepared to eat an expensive piece of cardboard if need be. I was blown away after walking in the front door and seeing a big open window to the pizza kitchen. As a former restaurant owner nothing pleases you more than a place that willingly shows you their kitchen, especially right inside the front door! It was so clean!! The ingredients on the cold table looked like they were just cut fresh. The SMELL!! OMG let me dig into one of those pizza pies!! We got 2 of the specialty pizzas and they were 🔥!! The toppings were just right and it was baked to perfection. The only thing that could have made it better would be a nice glass of cab in store but I settled with a glass of cab in a red solo cup in my room with my pizza pie!! I double locked the doors. Everyone I walked by twisted their head around to see the deliciousness I was escorting in the front door. SCORE!! P.S. Don't forget to get dessert! The carrot cake was so good if they had been open after the 1st piece I would have ran across the street for another!! Keep up the great work you guys have excellent...

I was staying across the street and decided to try it since this is close. The seating area is a lot smaller than you would expect. Consider how large the facility is. It certainly a higher end pizza then you're likely used to.

All the ladies working in the front were super friendly. They all worked in unison's. Taking care of all the tables. Had two different ladies check with me independent of my server. Really good customer service.

Apparently they have two different types of sauces, standard red sauce and a more sophisticated white sauce. The waitress suggested the white sauce was her favorite. She also said they could half and half any pizza if I wanted to try it. I did and I'm glad I did.

I did the Don Corleone which is effectively a fancy pepperoni pizza. The white sauce seemed to make a better pizza. Chris was nice and crunchy while the toppings were perfect for the size of the pizza. All of the rest of the diners around me who got larger pizzas had very good looking pizzas also.

Overall, I definitely recommend them. I mean I certainly appreciate cheaper pizza options, but this is a very good option. If you'd like to try something out of the box that's going to be very good. Highly...