Katy’s Log Cabin Restaurant — Restaurant in Oakfield

I brought a group of flatlanders up to Fond du Lac for a bike race. Many of them know my affection for wisco supper clubs and family restaurants. The pressure was on.

Katy’s was only a 15 minute drive from our hotels and had a menu with something for everyone. We shared some appetizers including the 3 for $12 assortment, who isn’t happy with fried cheese curds?!?

The salad bar was better than I expected from these reviews. They also had two soups, broccoli cheese and seafood chowder. Rolls and butter also available.

It being Saturday night we had Wisconsin’s greatest hits available - fish fry, broasted chicken, prime rib. So many potato choices. A small but clever hack of putting the butter pats inside the baked potato so the butter melts right on it. There was something for everyone, even one ice cream sundae made it to the table.

All of the staff was great but I especially want to shout out to our waitress Kendall. She likes her job and it shows. She said she’s been there for a few years and I hope that stays true when we come back for the race next year. She communicated proactively and by the end of the night we were communicating without even having to speak.

The food is very affordable and tasty. I...

Drove 30 minutes to have dinner here because we wanted to try something new and the reviews looked good. For a small town bar/restaurant I wasn’t expecting much, but even going in with low expectations it left much to be desired.

I got the Haddock Oscar with crab, asparagus and a cream sauce. Given the restaurant’s vibe (small dining room next to a rowdy bar, mounted deer heads on the walls, etc) this entree seemed out of place from the rest of the menu. The “crab” was imitation, which I should have expected. The cream sauce was a grainy, gelatinous consistency and didn’t taste right at all. The whole meal was bland, not worth the $17 by any means. My boyfriend had the battered walleye which was just okay. The service wasn’t great either. Overall this experience was just...

Food was very good. Drinks were good. Bartenders were great. Got seated in a reasonable time. Didn't know salad bar came with our meal until sitting there 10 minutes after we ordered then the waitress told us. Salad bar was ok. Breadsticks tasted old, the cottage cheese had green chives or green onions over the top but the soup was really good. We ordered food to go also and that took forever, 40 minutes or more. I think when you have take out they should get salad or coleslaw with it if the price...