Country Cones — Restaurant in Ohio

On the front of the sign for Country Cones it boasts, "favorite ice cream shop in Plain Township". This is a strong statement seeing there is a few more icecream shops nearby. Seeing this I had to stop in and try the legendary ice cream. The service was good, the prices were aggressive in the ice cream market, and there was alot of customers in line for the best ice cream around. When I finally received my ice cream in excited anticipation I was sorely disappointed. Small portion sizes (compared to the competition), average ice cream flavor and worst of all it all smelled like a fryer with old grease. One bad experience obviously cannot dictate wether or not they are a good or bad ice cream shop, but one bad experience can keep me to my favorite ice cream shops like New Baltimore Ice Cream. maybe one day I try it again and am very impressed, however today was...

Ice cream was good, but not $13 a half gallon good. I asked if they could pack 3 flavors and was told they could. I ordered vanilla, banana and chocolate with peanut butter swirls and chocolate chunks. The vanilla tasted "thin" and not creamy and rich like I would have expected. The banana tasted like Laffy Taffy - which tastes nothing like real bananas. I wish it had been labeled so as I would have passed. The chocolate was good but not noticeably better than Breyers of the same flavor. Also, you would think that when I order 3 flavors in one half gallon they would know to pack it like Neapolitan. They packed it in layers top to bottom. The kid sitting at the counter processing my payment was not happy when I did not tip. Sorry, you did not deliver anything to me or wait on my table. Made me wonder if that's why they packed my ice...

DELICIOUS!!! I got the Lemon Cheesecake and it was some of the best ice cream I have ever had. I asked where they get their ice cream from and they said many different locations. Some being Perrys Ice Cream, Smiths, and possibly Hersheys. I’m not normally a fan of Perrys and Hersheys but this blew me away. While they do not make ice cream there, they are known for their ice cream sandwiches (which they make there) and their coney dogs. Of course I had to get one!! I said I wouldn’t eat the whole thing after eating a double scoop of ice cream BUT it was too...